Episode Transcript
[00:00:19] Speaker A: Now, gentlemen, we. We've already. I think we've all had different conversations with friends about whether or not this film will be in the upcoming Oscars. But just think now, in an alternate reality, if current Jack Nicholson was Digger himself, would he automatically just be in there just because of the revelry and just the beloved popularity that is Jack Nicholson as a Persona, per se?
[00:00:50] Speaker B: I think he absolutely would because he's just been gone for so long.
[00:00:53] Speaker A: Yeah,
[00:00:54] Speaker C: yeah. That it would be a huge, like, comeback movie for sure.
The movie probably would have done a lot better, maybe, oh,
[00:01:02] Speaker B: 100%
[00:01:03] Speaker C: just because of the draw of, like, oh, Nicholson's
[00:01:05] Speaker A: back.
[00:01:06] Speaker B: I don't know that physically he could even do something like that, though. I mean, he's going to be 90 next year.
[00:01:11] Speaker C: It would be a very different digger, that's for sure. It would be a much more like calcified digger.
[00:01:17] Speaker A: I feel like oil rig Digger is how he dresses in. In retirement.
[00:01:22] Speaker B: Yeah. You're probably not too
[00:01:23] Speaker A: far or in his, like, silk pajamas,
[00:01:27] Speaker B: right?
[00:01:27] Speaker C: Yeah.
[00:01:27] Speaker A: The best part is I think if he was Digger, Inuriti would still put old age makeup on him.
[00:01:35] Speaker C: Age him up to 120.
[00:01:37] Speaker B: Right.
[00:01:40] Speaker A: Oh, God. That was. That was my idea for the cold open. Hello, everyone.
I'm looking so much. This is Odd Tril. Just Logan and Andy.
[00:01:48] Speaker C: I'm Andy Carr.
[00:01:49] Speaker A: And on Odd Trilogies, we take a trio of films where they're tied by cast and crew thematic elements or just numerical order, and we discuss the good, the bad and the weird surrounding each one of them. And today, in honor of this month being, of course a time to be thankful for so many things, we, of course, in terms of movies, is the beginning of a lot of Oscar nominees, a lot of big festival films that are finally getting larger releases.
And we thought it'd be interesting to try a new type of series, a sub series, of course, a part of the Odd Trilogies podcast where we basically take a very small select people who have won three of one specific award and talk about the reasons and also the films surrounding what led them to win those awards. And we are calling it Jack Nicholson's Oscar Trilogy. But of course, we are not doing it alone now, are we?
[00:02:45] Speaker C: No, we're absolutely not. We are joined by a veteran of the pod, a good friend, a massively respected colleague, writer, co editor, co founder, or editor co founder over at Midwest Film Journal. You know him? We know him. Everyone should know him. He's Nick Rogers.
[00:03:10] Speaker B: Hello. Thanks for having me. That's a hell of an introduction. I don't know how I can live up to that, but, you know, I'll take massive respect, even if it's just from a couple of people, a couple of fine people like yourselves. That's very kind of you.
[00:03:26] Speaker C: Thank you for gracing us with your presence on this one.
[00:03:29] Speaker A: Absolutely.
[00:03:30] Speaker C: Of
[00:03:30] Speaker B: course. Yeah. I'm always, always glad to be here. I feel like this is like my annual appearance on the podcast now. It's three. Three years straight.
[00:03:38] Speaker C: Yeah. Yeah. We've had you for Kevin Costner.
[00:03:41] Speaker B: Correct.
[00:03:43] Speaker C: And, God, what was the last one?
[00:03:44] Speaker B: Naked Guns.
[00:03:45] Speaker C: Oh,
[00:03:45] Speaker A: yeah,
[00:03:46] Speaker C: the Naked Guns last year. Yeah.
So, I mean, you've got quite the variety in your odd trilogy's repertoire.
[00:03:53] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:03:53] Speaker C: You know, you've got an actor turned director trilogy, you've got a comedy trilogy, and now you've got Oscar prestige in your trilogy.
[00:04:04] Speaker B: I contain multitudes.
You're
[00:04:06] Speaker A: finally talking about James L. Brooks on the podcast. I know you've been really mean to do that.
Been
[00:04:13] Speaker B: nagging you about it for years.
[00:04:15] Speaker A: Absolutely. You said, listen, Costner's a great choice, but James L. Brooks is there.
We need to talk about it.
[00:04:23] Speaker C: Look, I'm just glad that you had energy and that you've recovered from your subspecies adventure that you were able to join us for this.
[00:04:32] Speaker B: Yeah. Even the worst James Brooks movie is probably better than. Yeah. Any of the subspecies movies, so.
[00:04:40] Speaker A: Well, I guess the question is, how many Terms of Endearment films are there? Two.
[00:04:43] Speaker B: Two.
[00:04:44] Speaker A: There's two. But how many? I think people would.
[00:04:47] Speaker B: Six. Yeah.
So
[00:04:49] Speaker A: it's three
[00:04:50] Speaker B: Terms of Endearments.
Yeah. Terms of Endearment is not the sort of movie that anyone would probably expect to have a sequel. And I have not seen that sequel, but
[00:04:58] Speaker A: it does
[00:04:59] Speaker B: exist and is apparently pretty bad.
[00:05:01] Speaker A: Yeah.
[00:05:02] Speaker B: And James L. Brooks had nothing to do with it
[00:05:04] Speaker A: either. Apparently, it's based off of. Because Terms of Endearment is based off of a novel. And I think E means star, which is the sequel book as well as the sequel films title.
Yeah, they based it off a book, but I think the first review I saw on Letterboxd said Hallmark esque.
And that was kind of enough for me to be like, okay,
[00:05:24] Speaker B: yeah, I guess Nicholson's in it briefly, but that has never. I mean, I had not seen Terms of Endearment up until prep for this, so I. Obviously it would be weird for me to have seen the sequel, but I'm not particularly compelled to watch it still.
[00:05:40] Speaker A: Well, it's crazy, too, because going into this trilogy and now I wanted Nick to be introduced first before I said all three of these films because surprisingly, going into this trilogy didn't realize two out of three of these were fucking James O. Brooks's films. This is like the introduction of James O. Brooks to the pod, which, in case you don't know what the three films Nicholson won Oscars for, it is 1975's One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest, 1983's Terms of Endearment, in 1997's as Good as it Gets. And to also clarify, both Cuckoo and As Good as it Gets, he won best actor. While it's. In terms of Endearment, he won best supporting Actor.
And yes, it has a female led cast. Don't run away. He's. He's a. He's a fun part in terms. We will talk about that with terms. But yeah, I mean it's. I think it's a good one to start with Nicholson because of course, when we initially had this idea for the Oscars trilogy, the first one that came to mind, I think to both of us was Daniel Day Lewis. Because I think Lewis is
[00:06:41] Speaker B: Sure.
[00:06:41] Speaker A: Because it's a very small selection of people that have these.
[00:06:45] Speaker C: Yeah. It's a company of three that have three acting Oscars and four that have three or more.
Katharine Hepburn has four and then Nicholson, Meryl Streep and Daniel Day Lewis each have three. So yeah, it's now Sean
[00:07:02] Speaker B: Penn does too, after last year. Yeah.
[00:07:05] Speaker A: Oh my gosh. We could talk about Sean Penn on the podcast.
[00:07:09] Speaker B: Oh, we'll talk about Sean Penn today. You just don't know in what context.
[00:07:13] Speaker A: I love how Nick said that as a threat, but I'm excited.
[00:07:16] Speaker B: Oh, it's a threat. This particular Sean Penn movie is a perpetual threat as far as I'm concerned.
[00:07:23] Speaker A: Oh, God. I think now I know what you're talking about.
[00:07:26] Speaker C: You like Nicholson. I love him.
[00:07:29] Speaker A: Love him.
Jack Nicholson as an actor is so wild to talk about because of course how long his career spanned and considering.
The funny thing about these three Oscar wins is the fact that it's his 70s win, his 80s win and his 90s win.
And it's interesting to look at these wins surrounding. And we'll talk a little bit about it as well. Like the films he was going up against in the performance performances he was going up against.
Because I gotta say, it's wild the other two of all three years, what people he was up against as well as the big films at the time because. Right.
And also I think I already said it before, but just to clarify Terms of Endearment and as good as it gets for James L. Brooks. Well, our first film today is Milos Foreman, a director who, surprisingly, had less on his filmography than I expected. I mean, I feel like I've watched. I didn't realize I had watched a Milo film before this, which was man on the Moon, which I love.
And I think that was his second to last film.
I believe
[00:08:37] Speaker B: that's right. Yeah, that sounds right. It definitely is his last major film. That got a lot of traction, for sure.
[00:08:46] Speaker A: Yeah. But this is, I believe, because he was he a documentarian before and then went into narrative.
[00:08:52] Speaker B: I believe so. I believe that's. I believe that's right.
[00:08:55] Speaker A: Because another thing, too, about at least the first film on our docket today is that this film is a film that was basically in the works for at least a decade. Specifically, this was a Kirk Douglas vehicle film in the 60s.
Which is why when I was surprised when. Cause I will be honest, I had not seen any of these films in full going into this trilogy. One has been on my list. One Flew the Cuckoo's Nest has been on my list forever. But that's one of those films similar to, I would say, Godfather and others, where it's like, through osmosis. I have seen and heard most of the beats. The big beats in One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest
[00:09:33] Speaker B: sure
[00:09:34] Speaker A: doesn't get. Doesn't take away from their impact. Watching the film in full, it's actually watching the film in full, it's almost like deja vu being like, oh, now I see this in context.
But it is kind of fascinating just finally going into this movie and realizing that, like, oh, my God, Nicholson, this is like the film that really builds him out.
And the fact this was. This was a Kirk Douglas vehicle that ultimately ended up being a Jack Nicholson vehicle that also, I think kind of started or at least solidified Michael Douglas's relationship with Jack to the point where they're like best friends, literally. When I was looking up all three of these films and also just clarifying how old Jack Nicholson was because, like, my brain, because, again, being like, at our ages, it's like Jack Nicholson has always been old.
So I've never really thought about it. It's like the Tommy Lee Jones effect, where it just feels like he's always looked like that when in reality, no, people. People are young.
That crazy factor. But looking it up, apparently, like, the one person that knows how Jack Nicholson is doing right now, as of right now, is Michael Douglas.
[00:10:44] Speaker B: Yeah, I just saw that the other day that. I mean, it was
[00:10:46] Speaker A: very.
[00:10:47] Speaker B: Yeah,
[00:10:48] Speaker A: it's very sweet to be like Michael Douglas is being like, I will be the representative of Jack Nicholson because he doesn't want to talk to you. He's doing fine.
But.
[00:10:58] Speaker C: But yeah, I mean the man has been.
I think his first feature film was in 58.
[00:11:04] Speaker A: Yeah.
[00:11:04] Speaker B: And
[00:11:05] Speaker C: his last one was in 2010, so.
[00:11:07] Speaker B: Which is also a
[00:11:08] Speaker C: James L. Brooks
[00:11:09] Speaker B: movie.
[00:11:10] Speaker C: Yeah,
[00:11:10] Speaker A: yeah. God.
[00:11:12] Speaker C: About. No. Was it about Schmidt? No,
[00:11:16] Speaker B: About
[00:11:16] Speaker C: Schmidt was 2003.
[00:11:17] Speaker B: How do you know was his last name
[00:11:20] Speaker C: that was
[00:11:20] Speaker B: James L. Brooks? Yeah, yeah, yep.
[00:11:24] Speaker A: Gosh. How do you know?
[00:11:26] Speaker B: He's been rumored for a lot of things since then. I think there was talk that they were gonna remake that movie, Tony Erdman, which is a great movie and he would have been great for a part like that, but that just never happened. And you know. And of course, you know, theoretical digger.
[00:11:43] Speaker A: Yeah, I think he's gonna be. I think he might be Bond.
[00:11:49] Speaker C: He's the secret
[00:11:52] Speaker A: Calum Turner. Jack Loudon.
[00:11:53] Speaker B: Right.
[00:11:54] Speaker A: The one other guy. And Jack Nicholson.
I mean. Yeah, it's because when I think of Jack Nicholson, I think of. I base like his 80s to 90s run. And then of course I think a lot of people, especially modern sense when they think of Nicholson Departed.
[00:12:13] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah.
[00:12:14] Speaker A: As well as I guess if you talk about just in terms of Internet or meme culture, he's very. I think there's like a one specific meme of Jack Nicholson, I believe from anger Management
[00:12:23] Speaker B: early
[00:12:24] Speaker A: 2000s film where he's got like this devilish like nod to him.
[00:12:27] Speaker C: Yeah,
[00:12:28] Speaker A: I've seen that a thousand times over.
Almost more than I've seen the film Chinatown in minutes.
It's just like this interesting thing of just his status and his popularity as well as just like taking. Going back from 2026 to 1975 to watch this film and realize just like the intricacies of the character he's playing and how like just in general, whoever was going to play this role even before it was Nicholson had so many hoops they had to go through in terms of making this guy a likable, approachable protagonist. Because the film, in case you don't know about One Flew of the Cuckoo's Nest, it was a very popular novel at the time. That was basically the rights were very like sought after and Kirk Douglas and you know, they got the rights and they couldn't get it be made. And then ultimately when they got the film made, Nicholson got the lead part. And it's about a violent prisoner who is basically trying to use the system to his advantage by pretending to Be crazy, or at least you mean act a little bit more manic than usual in order to be put in a psych ward to have an easier sentence.
And ultimately leads him to build rapport with the other patrons at the ward as well as ultimately becoming a better person. Kind of a coming of age a little bit with some of the people in the ward having discussions about health care and real life.
They go fishing at one point, which is really fun.
But basically he's like, they. He is in prison for a bunch of violent offenses as well as. Is it statutory? Don't they just. That
[00:14:14] Speaker B: is.
[00:14:14] Speaker C: Yeah, that's one of them. One of them.
[00:14:16] Speaker A: Literally they go.
[00:14:17] Speaker B: That's one of them.
[00:14:18] Speaker A: They go, violent offense, violent offense, violent offense. Also statutory rape of a 15 year old.
And then his response is in the most Jack Nicholson way possible.
To be honest. She looked 18 to me and I, she told me she was 18 and to be
[00:14:35] Speaker B: like, says something like, she's going on 35 or something.
[00:14:37] Speaker C: Yeah, yeah.
[00:14:38] Speaker B: I was like, oh,
[00:14:39] Speaker A: once you see under the hood or something, like, it literally was like, holy shit. I know he's gonna succeed because I know how popular this film is and it was such a hit at the time, but holy shit, this is. Yeah,
[00:14:52] Speaker B: they would not make a version of that today that would include the statutory rape aspect of
[00:15:02] Speaker A: that,
[00:15:02] Speaker B: I think.
[00:15:03] Speaker C: Yeah, he would have to just be like battery and robbery or something. Right,
[00:15:07] Speaker B: Right.
[00:15:08] Speaker C: Yeah, you couldn't, you couldn't sell that today.
[00:15:11] Speaker B: But, but at the same time, I mean, it's. I didn't, I didn't rewatch it and think like, oh, you know, I mean, it's like. But, but I think that that's what, that's what makes the movie.
It gives it a little more tension, even though it doesn't really come up again because you're like, no, like, this guy is a criminal.
[00:15:28] Speaker A: Yeah.
[00:15:29] Speaker B: You know, I mean, he's not in there.
[00:15:30] Speaker C: He's a scumbag.
It's not like he just had a hard life or whatever. Like, he's kind of a piece of shit.
[00:15:38] Speaker B: Right? He's not a, you know, he's not a product of the system. He's like, no, he's a scumbag criminal. And, you know, he, he is absolutely doing what Logan says. He's trying to skate out the rest of his most recent assault charge. Right? Yeah, yeah.
[00:15:56] Speaker C: And yeah, I mean, that's a tough, tough line to walk that I think Nicholson is kind of perfect for. Where, like, from the jump. I mean, even after the statutory rape thing, Came up. You know, I hate to say it, like, he's. He's charming in every scene. I mean, even when he's being a douche, you know, he's like. You're like, man, this guy's just kind of got something to it.
[00:16:25] Speaker B: Well, and you. The thing. The thing that was really interesting to me watching it more, you know, through what he's doing in it, is the second he shows up, you can sense he's treating it like a prison in a certain way, albeit without maybe the physical threat, or at least what he perceives to be no physical threat in that he's sizing people up. He's sort of sussing out, like, who can I influence? Who can I. You know, who's, you know, like the big bull is, of course, Nurse Ratched. Right. But I mean, among the fellow members of the psych ward, he's trying to determine, like, you know, who do I have to bring over to my side who's dominating the conversation in these group therapy sessions, things like that? I mean, you see him sort of plotting it as he would in a prison anyway.
So, you know, he's definitely working an angle. I mean, and I think that what kind of the miracle of that movie is that it isn't a terribly touchy feely journey that he goes on. And obviously where it ends is not a happy destination for him.
But it is interesting that with all of that, that he does make you as Andy. You were saying it does make you like you are charmed by him. I mean, it works on you as much as it does any of the other men in the ward.
[00:17:53] Speaker C: Right?
Yeah,
[00:18:01] Speaker B: No,
[00:18:01] Speaker A: I mean, genuinely
[00:18:02] Speaker C: as well said.
[00:18:03] Speaker A: Yeah, absolutely. Like, it really is kind of. It becomes. If you are watching this for the first time, the. The question might be, all right, how am I going to just care about this man for two hours?
And ultimately what becomes is this fascinating kind of angle where it's like, well, you, the audience, are not a violent prisoner. But at a certain point, you see that Nicholson's journey as this character, when he realizes what this ward means to this person, that person, the situations, the way that they're treated in terms of being all adult men on this side of the ward, as well as they're gonna treat it like children.
And also, the. I think one thing I actually had no idea about going into this film, bit of a reveal, is the fact that a lot of them are self.
Brought themselves into the ward.
And that's kind of crazy thing of him realizing, I mean, that he had it so Much better in a lot of ways in terms of the freedom that he did have, of course, before going to prison, but ultimately realizing that he has had more time as a real person than it feels like that anyone else really has. And so he becomes this like.
Yeah, he becomes a progenitor for a lot of bad choices for a lot of these men in terms of the like, you know, obsessive drinking, breaking the rules, basically leading to a lot of delinquent behavior from people who have never really lashed out like that. But ultimately also giving these men a voice that they thought they never had or lost at one point. And
[00:19:37] Speaker C: he's. He's giving them a voice and he's also, you know, it feels like he's trying to inject his idea of what, like, truly living your life is into theirs. Where a lot of these guys have kind of given themselves over to not just the ward, but to their, you know, their own, you know, limitations and disabilities and things. And he's like, you know, he's trying to get them to kind of like get outside themselves and live a little bit. And that's. It's really endearing. Even when, yeah, he's breaking rules that are in place for very good reasons and, you know, putting them in danger at certain points.
[00:20:22] Speaker B: Well, I think what's interesting, and I'm glad, Logan, that you brought up, I mean, that moment when he finds out that so many of them are there of their own choosing is a really powerful moment in the movie. Just in the dramatic moment, but also for kind of how he as a character perceives what he's doing moving forward. Right. I mean, and the decisions he's making. And I think one of the things that I think has become maybe a knock against one flu over the cuckoo's nest is its. It's a dated depiction of mental health treatment. You could argue Even in 1975, it was a dated depiction of mental health treatment because it was 12 years in the past at that point. Now, I think when he's, you know, when he's shouting at them, you know, like, why are you here? Why don't you leave? I don't. What I don't think the movie is saying is like, you don't have a problem. You don't need to be here at all. I think what he's saying is there are more productive ways in the larger world for you to, you know, to face what your hang ups are and be with people rather than be, you know, cooped up in here. Right.
And, you know, ultimately that is the Undoing, you know, for him and several other characters in the movie. But that was something that kind of struck me this time, and I actually hadn't seen this movie since I watched it the first time, which was broken up over several days in my high school psychology class.
[00:21:43] Speaker A: Oh, wow.
[00:21:44] Speaker B: So, I mean, it's been more than 30 years. Years since I've seen it at this point. But I. I did see it. I mean, I remembered all of it so vividly because it's kind of like it was a movie that I saw at the right time, you know, I mean, the. You know, the whole entirety of the last act was really just kind of like burned into my brain because I. You know, when it was over, like on the, you know, Thursday psychology period that we watched it or whatever, I was like, holy shit.
You know, I don't think it's an indictment of mental health treatment per se. I think it's still really play. I mean, it is in a way, but I think what it really plays at is just that indictment of power and neutralization and the idea that it's easier to chemically castrate a problem than it is to really address it. Right. I mean, whether your problem is your inability to satisfy your wife sexually or that you're a violent criminal with five assault charges and a statutory rape charge.
[00:22:51] Speaker C: Yeah,
[00:22:53] Speaker B: but. But. But, yeah. I mean, I.
I think that within the context of that, I mean, it's easy to look back on it now, too, and say, oh, this is just Jack Nicholson being Jack Nicholson. But I think there's a lot of, like, really interesting, nuanced things that he's doing in this that aren't just like, the larger than life Persona, too.
[00:23:15] Speaker A: Yeah, I mean, he very much like. Because we'll talk about it later with the other two, especially with the last one. Because a fascinating thing about the last film in this trilogy is the fact that, like, that was the film. I think out of all three of these, he had the most struggle with. Because as an actor, Nicholson is a dedicated actor. He loves picking roles where he feels like this stimulates me mentally trying to get into the head of this person and actually make this person likable, engaging, empathetic. And ultimately, with this film, it's like it's also just a play with the right group of people. Because I would say with all three of these films, and I think, like, our talented people in all three of these movies, it's fucking crazy to watch this movie now and see Jack Nicholson bounce off of a young Danny DeVito who shows up Again in a very small role in terms of Endearment, Christopher Lloyd, another. A young Christopher Lloyd. And then also the youngest out of the four of them. A fucking Brad Dourifies.
I think he has to be. He looks like a child. Like he's so young. And also you can, like, in case you don't know out there, Brad Dourif is an esteemed character actor. He's mostly known for playing Chucky in the Chucky franchise, but he's a fantastic voice actor. The man has.
When he like does 50% on his yell, that's like a 93 for most people. Like, he just, he has a scream that just like, like rattles your bones. He even has one in this movie.
[00:24:51] Speaker B: Yeah, he. He was Oscar nominated for, for his role also. Yeah.
And. And what's funny is I had read Michael Douglas was thinking, like, if I'm going to be in this movie at all, it's probably just as Billy Bibbit. And that would not have worked.
[00:25:08] Speaker A: That would have been so crazy because Brad's doing it. Like. Yeah, it's like watching all these talented actors. And those are just the other three that I know the names off the top of my head. Because the other people who also play in that space, you can feel with Foreman's directing, they're given an openness that's not full blown improv, but willingness to like, they know their lines, they can do it at their own pace. We're not going to worry too much about placement of the camera, but we have it here. Let's do it like this. We'll try this and that. Like very much a lot of playing with what the edit will look like as well as just seeing how these actors play together in these big ensemble scenes. Because there's a lot of hunt. It's like mostly ensemble scenes, I would say, in this movie.
[00:25:54] Speaker B: Well, one of the things that I really keyed into to a point where I went back and rewatched it because I was like, I think they got the numbers wrong. But I also just wanted to watch it because I was like, this just is a great scene. The scene where he's trying to whip the vote to get them to air the World Series game. And he gets what he thinks is a unanimous nine to nothing vote. And Nurse Ratched tells him, well, there are nine other men on the ward, Mr. McMurphy, you don't have their vote. And the vote is nine to nine, you know, and so, you know, it's not a majority vote. And she, I think she gets the number Wrong. Because technically there are no other votes. They just haven't voted yet. It's not a 9 to 9 vote. But then he gets it wrong and he says something like, it's 10 to 9, and he's, like, screaming at her.
And it's a great moment because they both get the number wrong, but it's like that is what people who are on the verge of just completely losing it on each other would probably do in an argument like that. I mean, they're not even really thinking rationally. And so to me, that's just a great moment and a terrific bit of foreshadowing and precursor to the moment when he does lose it on her.
[00:27:05] Speaker A: Yeah.
[00:27:06] Speaker B: Which is.
I mean, there are.
You mentioned Logan. There's a lot of ensemble work in this, and that is obviously the meat of the movie, but there are several physically punitive sequences in this that. That, you know, you watch it and you think like, holy shit. Like, how did they do that without, you know, somebody actually injuring themselves? I mean, there's a moment where, you know, Randall McMurphy is. Is being subjected to a certain type of treatment. And the. The physicality of that. I mean, you. You feel like he's gonna break the bit that they put in his mouth.
[00:27:40] Speaker C: Yeah,
[00:27:41] Speaker B: it's very upsetting. It's purposefully upsetting.
And then, of course, at the end where he finally loses it, for reasons we won't spoil here, and goes after Nurse Ratched physically. I mean, it looks like he's about ready to just literally kill Louise Fletcher at that moment. I mean, I'm sure that it was safe and done in a way that it wasn't actually harming her, but the trickery that existed in 1975 was much different than the trickery that would exist for that now.
[00:28:10] Speaker A: Yeah,
[00:28:10] Speaker C: right.
[00:28:11] Speaker A: And also.
[00:28:11] Speaker C: Well, and the protocols maybe not all in place in the 70s.
[00:28:18] Speaker B: Yeah. Yeah, that's true. Not
[00:28:20] Speaker C: saying. Not accusing Jack Nicholson doing anything to Louise Fletcher, but
[00:28:25] Speaker B: they
[00:28:25] Speaker C: just did shit for real back then sometimes,
[00:28:27] Speaker A: honestly. Yeah. And speaking of Louise Fletcher, because again, when we're talking about Nurse Ratched, I think in terms of polls, when people talk about people's like, the worst villains and a film over history, Nurse Ratched does get put in those lists a lot. I will also need to bring up the fact that when we talk about One Float the Cuckoo's Nest, yes, we are specifically talking about Nicholson's performance as well as just the film in general. But One Flew With a Cuckoo's Nest is also in a very small subsection of films that actually won all five major categories the year it came out, which was Director, Actor, Actress, Picture, and then Best Adapted Screenplay.
[00:29:08] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:29:08] Speaker A: Which is crazy, because I think the other two are. I was looking like, yeah, 1934. That happened one night. And then 91, Silence of the Lambs. And I don't think that's changed since. Like, it's. And it's watching this movie again, because I understand when we're talking about a film from 1975 that has been so well regarded, it's also, I think, an AFI's top 100 films of all time, one of the greatest films ever made.
You spend so many decades talking about this film being one of the best films ever made. And there is usually a point in the zeitgeist, culturally, where you go, is it even really that good?
Maybe it was good for 75. Maybe I even say 85.
But really, by 90s, is it still good? And I have to say, as someone who's never seen it in full until 2026, this movie deserves all the accolades it got at its time. Like, it's fantastic because it's just.
[00:30:03] Speaker B: Yeah, I agree.
[00:30:04] Speaker A: It really. It's a film that has all those big moments that we've been talking about that are, like, the reason why people talk about these big moments because of how well done they are. But ultimately, my favorite moments while watching this are the little subtle things that happen, whether between two actors or one. Like, Louise Fletcher earned the Oscar for Best Actress just on stairs alone. If you didn't even have her say a single line, that would have gotten her the Oscar already. Because she has such an intense, pensive stare that is so piercing and also speaks volumes every time that. It's just like, when she doesn't speak, it's like, I'm afraid about what this woman's about to say.
[00:30:51] Speaker B: Yeah, it's interesting. I'm glad you brought up the villain thing.
On one hand, yes, a terrific antagonist.
I think what's kind of interesting is that the movie, without ever really underlining it, kind of makes you think that is a woman who was probably marginalized at every other opportunity she'd ever.
Or denied any opportunity that she might have wanted and here in the ward, has the power to, you know, dictate what happens to these guys. Because the men who are in power, who they do show, are, you know, busy dicking around on their boat and catching fish and debating, like, how dangerous are these guys really with their advanced degrees. Right. And I think that the movie doesn't like, yes, she's an antagonist. And yes, she is the reason why what happens happens. But I don't look at her as a villain in the way that I do. To mention another movie you referenced that I do. Hannibal Lecter as a villain, you know, who is actively manipulating the situation to get exactly what he wants. I don't know that, you know, she is, but she is within her own. What you perceive to be. This is probably the only sphere of power she'll ever have.
[00:32:15] Speaker A: Yeah.
[00:32:16] Speaker B: And there's no big social moment where she brings that up or reveals that it's not trying to humanize her. But I think it's just interesting within the film's critique of power and how it oppresses people. I think that's something that kind of gets overlooked just by how sensational she is at those moments of confrontation. But I think it's there in what she's doing, too.
And it's just another terrific performance to counter Jack Nicholson's.
[00:32:42] Speaker A: Yeah. Cause she. I mean, because at a certain point, the film becomes. Oh, this is now a film between a lovable asshole who has no right being here and is abusing the system to be in this kind of, I guess, cushy idea of, like, what his time is served versus a monster at times, to what they see they perceive as, like, an evil woman that ultimately is just a woman that does abuse her power, but not all the time. She subtly knows how to manipulate the men, but not in a way that is, like, considered violent in any way, but, like, literally when she uses. I wonder how your mother would feel about this to Billy.
[00:33:24] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:33:25] Speaker A: I mean, immediately as I hear that, you hear that out of, like, if you hear that out of context, you're like, oh, so she must know his mom. But at the point of this film, you know how Billy's relationship with his mother is. So when she brings it up, it's hard not to be like, you bitch, I know what you're doing, and it's working.
And it leads to a horrible thing that is like, ultimately she doesn't cause it, but indirectly she is involved into why it happens.
[00:33:56] Speaker B: Sure. Sure.
[00:33:57] Speaker A: Leads to just, like, these moments. Because, again, I think with Milos behind the scenes, as well as, like, the adaptation of it all, there is such a nice gray area in a lot of scenes where it's like the scene where Randall gets physical with Ratchet, there is no. He doesn't have to do that. That is entirely his own choice.
[00:34:18] Speaker B: Sure.
[00:34:18] Speaker A: That leads to his. Leads to a downfall.
And because he had the way out, literally had a way out and he decided not to take it. And again, in a. In a protagonist sense, it does show how much growth he has, because by the time the film. Like, when the film begins, there's no feeling that he has anyone in his real life outside of prison or outside of the war that he really cares about.
[00:34:43] Speaker B: Right.
[00:34:43] Speaker A: Like, he only. The only other two people we see him be very chummy with are prostitutes.
[00:34:50] Speaker B: Right.
[00:34:50] Speaker A: So it's like.
[00:34:51] Speaker C: Right.
[00:34:51] Speaker A: And they know him by first and last name. So it's kind of situation where it's like, oh, yeah, this guy has so many domestic. Yeah. Like, violence charges on him and just like, you know, fighting in public. Like, clearly, he is someone who has pushed so many people away over the years, and one time he decides to fight for somebody else. It is in the wrong way.
It's a very fascinating kind of angle to that, and I think it shows something that, like, how Nicholson brings it again.
It's something too, where I feel like a lot of people when we talk about Oscar wins and because we've talked about, you know, like, Denzel's wins in the past when we did, like, how Denzel needs another Oscar trilogy. Like, why these. Why these three performances were ones where he, like, really put his all into and thought could get him another Oscar, as well as other performances that literally this year, with the rise of Craig, talking about Amy Madigan and about her win.
[00:35:49] Speaker C: But,
[00:35:50] Speaker A: like, a lot of the times when you have, like, what can constitute worth this win?
It's the easiest thing to say. But a lot of the time is just, like, the silence in between, like, watching an actor, like, envelop into that role or, like, just get a whole paragraph across just by a single stare or, like, a little laugh. Like, to me, Nicholson almost gets the Oscar immediately when he finds out the chief is faking it. That whole scene.
[00:36:18] Speaker B: Yeah, that's a great.
[00:36:19] Speaker A: Is incredible.
Like, it's so sweet. It's so just, like, the most giddy. You see him in, like, a childlike way. And it's the most comradery that he has with anybody else.
[00:36:31] Speaker C: Right.
[00:36:32] Speaker A: Only for him to immediately get put in and get electroshocked.
It's fucking crazy going from, like, this very sweet moment that it, like, shows a side of Randall we haven't seen to showing how good Nicholson is an actor by, like, acting out this intense pain.
Yeah. And
[00:36:54] Speaker B: of the three, this is the one where, like, when I was done rewatching it, I was like, this was. Of the three. This is the one where I was like, the win was for the Right role at the right time.
[00:37:09] Speaker C: Yeah.
[00:37:10] Speaker B: And I didn't feel that way about the other two, but we'll talk about those.
[00:37:13] Speaker A: We will. Yes.
[00:37:14] Speaker C: Totally agree.
[00:37:15] Speaker B: Logan, you said that you were gonna mention who he was up against.
[00:37:19] Speaker A: Yes, I was
[00:37:21] Speaker B: in this year
[00:37:22] Speaker A: because again, it's like it was. It's a banger year. It's a banger year when this comes out. And let me. Let me pull it up again because I just had the nominees.
[00:37:32] Speaker B: Sure.
[00:37:33] Speaker A: And they keep putting me in the 30s. Stop it. Take me to the 70s. Come on, that's enough.
Yeah. So 75 is the 48th Oscars he wins that year. And he's going up against Walter Matthaus as Willie Clark in the Sunshine Boys, Al Pacino as Sonny in Dog Day Afternoon, Maximilian Schell as Arthur Goldman in the man in the Glass Booth, and then James Whitmore as Harry S. Truman in the film Give em hell, Harry.
And honestly, again, just to also clarify, Pacino got a nomination a year prior for Godfather Part 2 and then the year before in Serpico.
Right.
[00:38:13] Speaker B: Well, Pacino never won until Scent of a Woman. Right. I mean, that was. Which was obviously written by the same person who wrote One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest, but obviously, well after
[00:38:26] Speaker A: Cuckoo's
[00:38:27] Speaker B: Nest.
[00:38:27] Speaker A: Anyway, Eddie, you've not seen Sense of a Woman, right?
[00:38:30] Speaker C: No, I've not.
[00:38:31] Speaker A: Oh, if I could find an excuse to subject
[00:38:33] Speaker B: I
[00:38:34] Speaker A: that movie.
[00:38:34] Speaker B: Love.
I love.
I love Scent of a Woman so much. Oh,
[00:38:40] Speaker C: okay. Wow.
[00:38:41] Speaker B: Yeah,
[00:38:41] Speaker A: you heard it here, folks. Nick Rogers loves a Scent of a Woman. Not decent.
[00:38:48] Speaker B: Nick
[00:38:48] Speaker C: Rogers likes smelling women.
[00:38:50] Speaker B: Well, you know,
[00:38:53] Speaker A: if
[00:38:53] Speaker B: that's the worst. If that's the worst thing that comes out of my podcasting adventures, that'd be okay.
[00:38:59] Speaker A: The disappointment in Nick's face. I feel bad. I feel bad.
[00:39:03] Speaker C: That's the new title of the episode,
[00:39:04] Speaker B: right? Yeah.
[00:39:06] Speaker A: Nick's Sentinel Woman.
[00:39:08] Speaker B: All right.
I mean, I hear that list of five, and admittedly, I think the only other one that I've seen is Dog Day Afternoon. Yeah,
[00:39:18] Speaker C: same.
[00:39:19] Speaker B: And I mean, it's a similar type of performance in that there is a grandiosity to what Pacino's doing, but there's also a humanity to what he's doing and a desperation to what he's doing in that movie. I mean, I would have to think Pacino was probably his best biggest competition among those five, just simply because, like, you'd mentioned that Pacino had been nominated in the previous two years and hadn't won. Was he nominated for the first Godfather also?
[00:39:46] Speaker A: I would assume so. But I didn't go that far back.
[00:39:49] Speaker B: I mean, at that point, you've got pretty much every single year of the decade this guy's been nominated and hasn't won yet.
But Nicholson hadn't won yet either. I mean, and I think Chinatown might have been the first nomination for him. Or maybe he was nominated for Five Easy Pieces. I'm not entirely sure.
[00:40:08] Speaker A: I will also say, though, because again, I try to remember, one of these categories is insanely stacked.
And of course, it's best picture for 1975.
[00:40:19] Speaker C: Yeah,
[00:40:19] Speaker A: that's one Flew Over, Barry Lyndon, Dog Day Afternoon, Jaws, and Nashville.
[00:40:26] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:40:27] Speaker A: Crazy. Yeah, crazy.
[00:40:30] Speaker B: Yeah. I mean, that's one where you could literally pick any one of the five and make a case for it being one of the strongest winners for, you know, of any.
You know, any winner. It's
[00:40:45] Speaker A: like the year that Crash won, right, Nick?
[00:40:48] Speaker B: Exactly like the year.
[00:40:51] Speaker C: Well, and I also like the way you describe it, Nick. Is the right performance at the right time, because,
[00:40:57] Speaker B: yeah,
[00:40:57] Speaker C: as Logan alluded to earlier, this was not like.
Even though it kind of feels like for maybe those younger of us, like, you know, one of the first movies where he was a big deal. This was his fifth acting nomination. Oscar nomination in six years.
[00:41:14] Speaker B: Oh, wow. Yeah. Okay.
[00:41:15] Speaker A: So, I
[00:41:16] Speaker B: mean, he was like Pacino. I mean, he and Pacino were
[00:41:18] Speaker C: kind
[00:41:18] Speaker B: of like the same.
[00:41:20] Speaker C: 69, 70, 73, 74, 75.
Nominated as either supporting or lead.
And, yeah, just to win here is like. Yeah, it feels, thinking back, like. Yeah, okay. He had a. He had a whole trail and lead up to this.
Of renown and good performances.
[00:41:39] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:41:40] Speaker C: Because Chinatown was the year before.
[00:41:42] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:41:42] Speaker A: I love him in Chinatown. He's so good.
Gosh. I mean. Yeah, it's. Again, yeah. Not saying that he completely came out of the blue when this movie. Sure. But it is.
[00:41:53] Speaker C: No, I wasn't implying that, but that is. I mean, that's how I thought of this movie, because I watched it as a kid with my parents. Maybe not a kid, but like a teenager or something.
And, Yeah, I mean, I thought of it as, like, wow, look how young Nicholson is he. You know, he must have really busted onto the scene with this movie.
And. No, he was. He'd been in the
[00:42:14] Speaker B: game for almost 20 years at that point.
[00:42:17] Speaker A: Because I believe he's 38.
That sounds right. Because, like.
[00:42:21] Speaker C: Yeah,
[00:42:21] Speaker A: because by the time we get to the last film in this trilogy, he
[00:42:25] Speaker B: ain't 38.
[00:42:26] Speaker A: That's
[00:42:26] Speaker B: for sure.
[00:42:26] Speaker A: He ain't 38 no more.
But, I mean. Yeah, it's. It is yeah. It is understandable. So that, like, I agree with you, Andy, that, like, growing up listening about how Nicholson is as an actor and being like, well, where did that start? It is kind of understandable that initially you think, oh, was he just kind of brought in out of the blue? And then so far, this movie just, like, wins for him, and it's like, no. Like, he is. He's an established actor where literally, he becomes so big at a certain point with. Even without an Oscar that they're, like, selling his, like, his small performance in Little Shop of Horrors. Like,
[00:43:04] Speaker C: right.
[00:43:04] Speaker B: Right.
[00:43:05] Speaker A: When he's, like, in two lines and he's not a prominent part of that film. And it's like, they're using that to sell that movie in the present day because the movie's not loved before. It's before the musical.
But. But look how nice. Look how nice and sleek he looks in this movie.
It's this kind of thing of he is that actor now that, like, of course, we live in an era where it's hard to even, like, now I can't. I can't even look at his son, who's now an actor, showing up in a lot more stuff, and I can't look at him and not think of his dad.
Iconic. His dad is.
But it is nice to watch this movie and almost, like, push the pedigree aside for at least two hours just to see, like.
Yeah, I get it. If for some reason I didn't get it before, I certainly get it now.
[00:43:52] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:43:53] Speaker A: In terms of how good of an actor he is. And I agree. Right. Right Character. Right. Win at the right time.
[00:43:59] Speaker B: He. He doesn't look sleek in terms of Endearment, though.
[00:44:02] Speaker A: Oh, my Lord,
[00:44:03] Speaker C: no.
[00:44:04] Speaker A: Do we have anything else we want to say about over One Flew over before we get into terms of Endearment?
[00:44:13] Speaker C: Just that Emma watched One Flew over with me, and it was her first time. And understandably, to anyone who knows her profession,
[00:44:22] Speaker A: she
[00:44:22] Speaker C: was deeply moved by multiple points.
[00:44:25] Speaker B: Yeah.
When you were talking about that, I was thinking that's where you're going with it. I was curious to know.
[00:44:31] Speaker A: Yeah, me too.
[00:44:31] Speaker C: Yeah.
[00:44:32] Speaker A: I will say, though, before we go on the next film, Chiefs, a real one. I love that man's performance.
[00:44:36] Speaker B: Yeah. And so
[00:44:37] Speaker A: good. He. He is. Even when he's not Randall's best friend, anytime he's on screen, I'm just.
Yeah. And also the guy from the original Hills have eyes with this, like, very iconic
[00:44:49] Speaker B: Michael Perryman.
[00:44:50] Speaker A: Yeah. The fact that he's the only guy that Randall won't With in the ward. Like there's one when he's trying to get the vote and he's like, no, nevermind. Right. He won't even touch him. I
[00:45:00] Speaker B: do love the shot of Chief walking back on.
On defense.
[00:45:05] Speaker A: Yes. Like
[00:45:07] Speaker C: so. Yeah.
[00:45:08] Speaker B: So good.
[00:45:08] Speaker A: It's so good. Yeah. One flew over. Worth all the hype. Still great in the 2020s. Excellent film.
Is it as excellent as Terms of Endearment? No, it's better. But we will talk about that.
Yeah. So now we're jumping to 1983 with James L. Brooks's directorial debut with Terms of Endearment based off of a novel of the same name.
And for those who might not know James L. Brooks off the top of your head, that the man. Before we get to Terms of Endearment and before we get to Nicholson's second win, he is prolific in the television space. Like Mary Tyler Moore show Taxi.
Like this man's name is attached to so many prolific shows in those early years, especially in the 70s, going into the 80s.
[00:46:00] Speaker B: Yep.
[00:46:00] Speaker A: And so of course, you know, Taxi, big show for so many actors, including Danny DeVito. So when he pops up in this, it's like, oh, of course he's here.
And ultimately for years, for decades after, even after the structural debut, even the ebbs and flows of Brooks career, still so many actors are just begging to work with him. Even when it's like, even if the material, I mean, I don't think they joined the film if they didn't think the material was there. But it is kind of wild that like we got a James L. Brooks's film last year with a very talented cast behind it, including.
Is it Julie Cavney?
Marge Simpson herself.
[00:46:40] Speaker B: Yeah, Julie Kavner. Yeah,
[00:46:41] Speaker A: Julie Kavner.
[00:46:42] Speaker C: Yeah.
[00:46:42] Speaker A: Which is crazy to see. And I've not seen that woman in live action in like decades.
And it's crazy to think that like, you know, even in 2025 there is a. There are people that are like, we want to work with James O. Brooks. And the reason why for at least in the film space starts with this starts with Terms of Endearment, a film that I think at least hilariously on Wikipedia, it calls it a tragicomedy. I think another way to describe is a dramedy or just a comedy drama.
[00:47:10] Speaker C: Sure.
[00:47:11] Speaker A: A generational coming of age story that follows like the 30 plus year span of a relationship between a mother and her daughter as the mother deals with becoming a widow and trying to find love again while the daughter tries her best not to become her mother.
And do things differently and ultimately leading to the ebbs and flows of their relationship as it changes over the years and they grow apart and the men that are kind of like the sideline in their lives.
And this movie was very weird, at least for my experience when I was watching, because I had never seen. When I think of James L. Brooks, unsurprisingly for a lot of people out there, he's also tied to the Tracey Ullman show, which introduces the Simpsons to everybody and is also a big proponent of the Simpsons. And so when I think of James O. Brooks, I think of the Simpsons because my. My grandpa has been a Simpsons fan for decades upon decades, and I've watched so many Simpsons over the years. And so when I see that name, I think of, like, the. The yellow font.
[00:48:16] Speaker B: Right?
[00:48:16] Speaker A: See James O. Brooks. Yeah,
[00:48:18] Speaker C: yeah.
[00:48:18] Speaker A: And also Gracie films. That was another, like, the. The logo and everything that. The Simpsons thing in my head. So, like watching James O. Brooks. And also, I believe this film.
The DP on this film is hilariously the director of Street Fighter, the Legend of Shen Li.
It
[00:48:38] Speaker B: all. It all. It all comes back.
[00:48:41] Speaker A: And also the director of the Dwayne the Rock Johnson's Doom adaptation.
[00:48:46] Speaker B: Yes.
[00:48:46] Speaker A: He's either the DP on this or I believe it's this one.
[00:48:50] Speaker B: It's this one.
[00:48:51] Speaker A: You're right. Someone's got as Good as it Gets. But yeah, I mean, in terms of the premise, it doesn't. It sounds pretty straightforward, and it really is until people start talking.
Then it becomes this really fascinating, like, oh, so this is the James L. Brooks film I've heard so much about. Like, these. Like, this style.
[00:49:15] Speaker B: Sure.
[00:49:15] Speaker A: So, Nick, why don't you take it over? Like, explain, like, how. So this is like your second time, or is this your very first time getting through
[00:49:22] Speaker B: this? No, I had not seen Terms of Endearment prior to this.
[00:49:25] Speaker C: New to all of us.
[00:49:26] Speaker B: Yeah. So.
So I was very familiar with a lot of other James Brooks films.
I have not yet seen Ella McKay,
[00:49:35] Speaker A: which
[00:49:36] Speaker B: is the one you were mentioning from
[00:49:37] Speaker A: last year.
[00:49:38] Speaker B: I've also never seen I Do Anything, which was rather infamously shot as a musical and then had such disastrous test screenings that they had to refilm and yank all the songs out of
[00:49:51] Speaker A: it. So crazy.
[00:49:53] Speaker B: But you know, his other.
The one for me, when I think of James L. Brooks, as far as movies go, I mean, I think of Broadcast News, which was also a
[00:50:02] Speaker A: very
[00:50:02] Speaker B: big Oscar contender four years after Terms of Endearment also has Jack Nicholson in it in a very small part, but an amusing Part, nevertheless.
But Terms of Endearment, definitely. I think so. I love broadcast news.
I hate Spanglish, which is his movie with
[00:50:24] Speaker A: Adam
[00:50:25] Speaker B: Sandler and Te Leone. Awful, terrible movie.
This one kind of splits the difference a little bit between those for me. I mean, I definitely think that I prefer James L. Brooks when he's being a little more whimsical than he is wistful about things. I mean, I think that, you know, at the risk of. Of slapping a spoiler Tag on a 43 year old movie whose turn into this territory is kind of well known, if you know anything about the movie, you know, this happens. The terminal illness aspect of Terms of Endearment is literally just like, okay, we need a third act now. Somebody's gonna die.
[00:51:07] Speaker A: Yeah, yeah.
[00:51:08] Speaker B: And to the credit of the performers in it, it's a lot more affecting than you would expect based on the way they introduce it. Now you could also say, well, Nick, that's how terminal illnesses come about. You just learn one day that you have them. And I get that, and I understand that, but that's not the movie that Terms of Endearment seems to be leading up to.
Up to that point, which makes it a little bit awkward, but.
So you're probably wondering, where the hell does Jack Nicholson fit in all of this?
He is the past, his prime, overweight, aging lothario who lives next to Shirley MacLaine's character somewhere in the suburbs of Houston.
And he's a former astronaut.
Which is. Which is a great. I mean, like, that's really funny. Just kind of on its face. Is that like Jack Nicholson is playing a former astronaut? That's kind of just funny to me in general.
[00:52:09] Speaker A: I mean, when we see his dining room and it's all of his medals, it's a picture of him in a suit.
Yeah, it's. Go ahead, Nick. I just wanted to
[00:52:19] Speaker B: show you. And Shirley MacLaine is like, this is all very sad.
She says something like, that's very funny.
What's funny is that to watch it now. I mean, at the time, it was maybe a little bit different for Jack Nicholson because it wasn't like the big larger than life caricature that he'd kind of, you know, he would become moving through the 80s, like he hadn't really done a whole lot of parts like that. But to look back on it now in retrospect, it's like this is kind of the genesis for that. And maybe winning the Oscar for it is why he leaned into it so much, you know, in the ensuing years. Because you know, you can see his name is also hilarious. It's Garrett Breedlove.
[00:53:01] Speaker A: Yes.
[00:53:03] Speaker B: You can see a lot of Garrett Breedlove in the Devil in the Witches of Eastwick. You can see aspects of Garrett Breedlove in the Joker in Batman.
You know, you basically see kind of the big like Jack larger than life elements. I mean, you see parts of him even in as Good as it Gets too. Even though it's completely different character.
But what's interesting is that he is the comic foil of the movie, but he also kind of becomes the unexpected emotional center of it when it does shift toward tragedy.
[00:53:39] Speaker A: Yes.
[00:53:40] Speaker B: And not in a big speechy way.
There's not a big moment.
He doesn't even talk to the person in this movie who is dying of cancer for more than 30 seconds.
You never see it.
But he does show up when that person is dying in a way that, you know, is also brief, but also, you know, kind of an unexpected, like the moment of him trying to find, you know, maybe an anchor to something more normal than just being an old astronaut that's taking women out who are too young for him anymore.
Something
[00:54:18] Speaker A: Jack Nicholson never did in his real life.
[00:54:20] Speaker B: Right.
[00:54:20] Speaker A: Yeah. He'll never do going into the 2000s or anything like that.
[00:54:24] Speaker B: Right.
But I guess for that reason, I mean, I think to me, I liked this movie. I enjoyed it. I did go into it knowing what James L. Brooks's general vibe was. So I did know.
But I do think the performances kind of save something that feels very episodic and doesn't exactly come together as like a full blown movie.
It works because of what Jack Nicholson's doing, what Shirley MacLaine's doing, what Debra Winger's doing and Shirley MacLaine as Louise Fletcher did in One Flew over the cuckoos. Now Shirley MacLaine also won an Oscar for her performance in this. So it's another. All of these movies have two Oscar winning performances in them, which is dawned on me.
Yeah. So I think that, I do think though that Nicholson maybe got kind of washed up in the sweep of. Of the love for this movie a little bit maybe, and why he won.
And I can talk about this more in a minute, but I don't think this was the right supporting actor Oscar for him at the right time. But we can get to that.
[00:55:32] Speaker A: No, for sure. I do think that a fascinating part about the film is that again, it is the mother and daughter dynamic that are the forefront of the film. And all the men are still side character. They're all secondary characters that Are like, they add. They add seasoning to the lives of both of these women in different ways. Where it's like Dan DeVito's character is very sweet on Shirley Mlan, who is the mother of the two and is very much just like wants. Just wants to be with. With her. And she always is like, no, not right now, but maybe later. Kind of that vibe with her.
Deborah Winger, who was nominated with Shirley McLean and Best Actress the year that Shirley MacLaine won for this Terms, is also the best Picture winner of 1983, if I remember correct as well.
[00:56:20] Speaker B: Yep.
[00:56:21] Speaker A: But the other, we have a young Jeff Daniels as Deborah Winger's horrible husband
[00:56:29] Speaker B: as a guy named Flap.
[00:56:32] Speaker A: Guy named Flap.
[00:56:33] Speaker C: Bum ass husband.
[00:56:34] Speaker A: And. But he's. And he is not the one nominated for a supporting actor from this with Jack Nicholson. It is John Lithgow,
[00:56:41] Speaker B: right?
[00:56:41] Speaker A: Yeah. Who is a. Literally when he shows up. I knew the cast going into this, but I forgot about Lithgow because the thing about this movie too is that you can go in knowing the cast when they pop in and out really just like throws you for a loop at times. Like.
[00:56:58] Speaker B: Yeah, that's true.
[00:56:58] Speaker A: DeVito has, I think four scenes, maybe five, and it's like the second to third scene of the film a little bit in the middle. And then the final scene, he's there
[00:57:12] Speaker B: barely doing anything.
[00:57:13] Speaker A: Yeah. Didn't probably know the person they're there for, but it is funny to think about, you know, John Lithgow's character love in this movie. But he's also not.
It doesn't feel like he's in this movie a lot. And so when it comes to like all the performances, these two that are nominated and ultimately won, Nicholson, I guess, does make the most sense because it does have this energy of. Well, of the secondary characters that are men, which one pops the most and which one are you like, kind of the most interested in when they show up? And it is the womanizing old astronaut who everyone goes, you're too old doing this. And has like, clearly is into Shirley MacLaine. But they are both just weird, pushy people that are clearly perfect for each other, but neither one of them want to be honest about each other's feelings until they do. And then it's weird still, but at least it's a fun, like, strong chemistry between the two of them. Even when they're being weird with each other.
[00:58:15] Speaker B: Yeah, I love. She describes him as a, quote, self centered and yes, somewhat entertaining man.
[00:58:21] Speaker A: Sherrod McClane is on one this whole movie. Easy,
[00:58:26] Speaker C: easy. To imagine a lot of the women in Jack Nicholson's life describing him.
[00:58:30] Speaker B: Of course. Yeah.
[00:58:31] Speaker C: Yeah.
[00:58:32] Speaker A: It's. God, when Jack Nicholson looks sure. MacLaine in the eyes and goes, you know, you're usually. You're a bit too old for me, but if you want to go to lunch, it's like, this is crazy.
[00:58:42] Speaker B: Right?
[00:58:43] Speaker A: Right.
[00:58:43] Speaker B: And then they. And then they don't even get together for, like, years after that conversation.
[00:58:47] Speaker A: Yeah. Because it's
[00:58:48] Speaker B: like, really funny
[00:58:49] Speaker A: because Nicholson basically.
Because this movie is 213, if I remember correctly, of the three films, One Flew over as the shortest. This is right in the middle and as good as it gets. It's nearly 220.
[00:59:02] Speaker B: Yeah.
[00:59:03] Speaker A: It's crazy because when Jack Nicholson, I think, finally gets aligned with Shirley MacLaine, it is 45 minutes into this two plus hour film. And again, once they start talking. Ugh.
He's. He's good. He is good in this movie. But I do agree with Nick that, like, of any supporting actor role that he would have been nominated for in his. In his career, this is not as perfect as One Flew Over.
It really frame.
[00:59:31] Speaker C: It really does kind of feel like, you know, a higher. Like, hey, come in here and be Jack Nicholson. You're going to stick out in this movie and it's going to be great. And like, that's. That's kind of all the role is aside, you know? And I mean, he's still Jack Nicholson. He's still very talented and brings, you know, some. Some pizzazz to it in those certain moments.
But, yeah, it really is like. It just feels kind of like the average Jack Nicholson
[00:59:58] Speaker B: performance
[00:59:59] Speaker C: or role. Yeah.
[01:00:00] Speaker A: James L. Brooks, which we get more of with as Good as It Gets, is almost like looking at him saying, say this heinous, mean, almost just misogynistic thing to this woman, but make it so charismatic because you're Jack Nicholson and you can take anything on the chin. And he's like the scene where the women are, like, making fun of how old he is and how pathetic. This is like the one friend. And then he goes like, stacy, would you like to come in? And it's like he completely just deflects the entire read that this man got. And it's just like, oh, God damn it. Yeah, it's Jack Nicholson. He could just make even the schlubbiest pervert.
[01:00:42] Speaker B: Well, so this was another movie that from a couple years earlier that was in the best picture mix, and for me of what I've seen from that year, frankly, should have won the Oscar for best picture was. 1981 is a film called Reds that Warren Beatty directed, starred in with Diane Keaton.
It's a story of John Reed, who was a writer and political influencer in his time during World War I.
And Jack Nicholson, among many incredible actors of the 70s and 80s, is in Reds, and he plays playwright Eugene O'. Neill.
He is.
I don't want to spoil too much of why he's great in Reds, but to watch it is to almost forget that you're watching Jack Nicholson, which is tough to do.
[01:01:40] Speaker A: Oh,
[01:01:40] Speaker B: damn.
[01:01:41] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:01:41] Speaker A: Okay.
[01:01:42] Speaker B: And he's so diminished and wounded and quiet in it that it's just mesmerizing. And he was nominated. I think he
[01:01:53] Speaker A: was. I just looked it
[01:01:55] Speaker B: up
[01:01:55] Speaker A: because I just saw who won that year. Absolutely insane.
[01:01:59] Speaker B: Who was
[01:02:01] Speaker A: is John Gielgud. He's Hopson.
Oh. For
[01:02:04] Speaker B: Arthur. I
[01:02:05] Speaker A: mean, you know, good performance.
[01:02:07] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:02:08] Speaker A: Crazy. That Arthur is. I didn't know.
[01:02:12] Speaker B: Yeah, I mean, I. I can't argue with that too much. I mean, John Gielgud is terrific in that movie, but I mean, I. I just. I do feel like maybe in a way this was a little bit of a make good for that because I feel like Reds was one of those movies that, I mean, Chariots of Fire, I know one best picture of the year it came out.
Warren Beatty did win for directing Reds. Reds is a very.
It's a very long, complicated film, but it's also immensely entertaining. Warren Beatty is a movie star and he knows that, like, this has to have movie star things happening in it if I'm going to get people to watch a three hour, 15 minute movie about political insurgency in World War I.
[01:02:54] Speaker A: Because I think when I hear about Reds, most people go, uh, that movie is so. It's. But it's,
[01:03:01] Speaker B: it's terrific. And Jack Nicholson's terrific in it. I mean, I'd be curious if you guys ever watch it. What you think? Honestly?
[01:03:07] Speaker C: Yeah. I mean,
[01:03:07] Speaker A: I'm definitely
[01:03:08] Speaker C: intrigued about it.
[01:03:09] Speaker A: Yeah. I will also say, because again, this is what happens when you look up. Because we could. I mean, there's definitely been podcasts about it, but just Oscar narratives of, like, actors who have been nominated before and leading into New Year's and like, why this, why this could have been their year, but didn't become this, like literally the year prior to this movie. In 82, both Lithgow and Charles Durning were nominated.
John Lithgow was nominated for the World According to Garp.
[01:03:37] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:03:37] Speaker A: As trans icon Roberta Muldoon, a very early trans character. Who is not.
Not played for jokes.
[01:03:46] Speaker B: Right.
[01:03:47] Speaker A: Not a stereotype, like genuinely a phenomenal, like interpret like the phenomenal character in that story. As well as Charles Durning being nominated for the Governor of Texas for the Best Little Whorehouse in Texas,
[01:04:01] Speaker B: also a great supporting performance. That's that. That he's terrific in that.
[01:04:05] Speaker A: And then literally a year later in this run when Nicholson wins best supporting Actor, Durning's nominated again for to be or not to Be. And then of course, Lithgow was nominated for Tourism Endearment as well as on top of that, Sam Shepard for the Right Stuff and Rip Torn for Cross Creek. That was the. For supporting actor at the time.
[01:04:25] Speaker B: Rip Torn, who of course should have won for Freddy Got Fingered.
[01:04:29] Speaker A: Oh, boys, get
[01:04:31] Speaker C: out of my goddamn scuba
[01:04:32] Speaker A: gear.
Incredible performance.
[01:04:36] Speaker B: I mean, I do
[01:04:36] Speaker A: feel
[01:04:37] Speaker B: like. I do feel like in a way that lineup for Nicholson here is maybe stacked a little bit in his favor to win.
[01:04:47] Speaker C: Sure.
[01:04:48] Speaker B: You know, smaller performances, you know, smaller movies outside of the right stuff, which was, you know, also nominated for best picture that year.
[01:04:57] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:04:59] Speaker B: So, yeah. I mean, I do feel like I'm trying to temper it by saying I don't think that he's bad in it. I don't think that he necessarily, you know, I can see why he won.
Even if I don't think it's of his supporting performances that he was nominated for, I don't think it's his best one.
[01:05:18] Speaker A: Yeah.
I mean, when you again with us and so many other people over the years, even if you don't notice it or clock it, but if you watch enough movies in your lifetime, especially if you watch enough Oscar nominated films or films trying to get Oscars, you can see in certain performances, oh, this is the moment where if they get nominated, it's going to be this clip. It'll be this clip or that clip. Like I think one of the most in my head, Notorious. But I think he's fantastic in this movie. But it's a recent example or recent. This century is a Ruffalo in Spotlight when Mark Ruffalo does his monologue.
[01:05:57] Speaker C: They knew and they did not.
[01:05:59] Speaker A: It's a great scene, but it's clearly, it's all. It's locked on him. It's nobody else. And it's like this is it.
[01:06:06] Speaker C: Pretty sure that scene, that shot even is like the impetus for the wah, I'm acting meme.
[01:06:15] Speaker A: But it's like
[01:06:16] Speaker C: which I love that performance in that movie. But. Yeah,
[01:06:19] Speaker A: but One Flew the Cuckoo's Nest, there are multiple scenes where you can be like, okay, this is why Nicholson, if he gets nominated. I can see this. I can see.
[01:06:26] Speaker C: Yeah, yeah.
[01:06:27] Speaker A: With this movie, I feel like there is a scene or two where I can see. Okay, this is probably. Probably what they used. I guess now we could just watch the footage back then and see what they used for the clip of that.
[01:06:38] Speaker C: I don't even know. Did they do clips back then?
[01:06:41] Speaker B: Yeah, I don't know
[01:06:43] Speaker A: that's actually.
But like,
[01:06:45] Speaker B: I, you know, I was. I was.
Let's see. I would have been four, so probably not yet. Watching the Oscars
[01:06:52] Speaker A: probably wasn't too
[01:06:52] Speaker B: much later. No, no,
[01:06:56] Speaker A: no. But like, I could see the airport scene where McLean. Yes. It's like, I love you. And it's like, how do you respond to that? And he's like, the way I do with everything else. I love you too, kid. Or something. Right. It's like
[01:07:08] Speaker C: the
[01:07:08] Speaker A: most Nicholson way to say that. But yeah,
[01:07:11] Speaker B: I love too. In that scene where he's like, I was this close to getting out of here. Yeah. You say something like that. Yeah.
[01:07:17] Speaker A: No, I mean, it's like, again, yeah, you can see with the. With a decent lineup, but also with him definitely being the forefront of it where, like, then you watch the movie and it is kind of like of all the. The supporting characters who. Again, I think everyone's doing a good job in this movie. I would argue that, like,
[01:07:35] Speaker C: sure.
[01:07:36] Speaker A: The film to me gets to be like a 7 out of 10. Mainly because of Deborah Winger and Shirley MacLaine in terms of their performances. Winger. Because even though I agree with you, Nick, that the third act twist turn into sadness is very strong.
It's very, like a sharp turn.
Deborah Winger is just killing it in that. That last
[01:08:01] Speaker B: scene with the kids. Oh,
[01:08:02] Speaker A: my God.
[01:08:03] Speaker B: Unbelievable.
[01:08:04] Speaker A: That that child. I just wanted to be like, make sure his. Either mom was on set or someone consoled him because I think he might have thought something bad was gonna. Right to
[01:08:15] Speaker B: Deborah Winger.
[01:08:16] Speaker A: Yeah. But it's like. But then in that. In that slew of, like, getting to the end of the film where you know what's gonna happen, because again, a big thing about Terms of Endearment and I think a James O. Brooks film, at least the two we watch for this, is that you kind of guess what happens 15 minutes before the act ends and it still keeps going. Then you get to that point, Eddie, when Nicholson shows up at the hotel to see Shirley, like a breath of fresh air. It just feels like, oh, my God, a little bit of a weight's been lifted and the Fact that he wasn't. Clearly wasn't asked to show up.
It's like a very sweet, tender moment that is like, oh my God. Especially because like the, for a lot of the film. I think this film has the classic case of. I assume the book does more with this because there's like especially their relationship. While it's good and I really love when we get moments to see a shine, there is a bit of, a little bit of a falling out between McLean and Nicholson that does feel also sharp, like a very short
[01:09:16] Speaker C: term. Yeah, it feels, it's. I mean this is one of those movies where it feels like the, it spans so much time and the time jumps seem to like hamper your attachment to the characters and their relationships and like the journey they're going on. And I, Yeah, I wonder if that's something that like is just how the movie condenses the story. I don't know.
[01:09:41] Speaker B: I've not read
[01:09:42] Speaker C: the book,
[01:09:42] Speaker B: so I don't know. But it
[01:09:43] Speaker A: does,
[01:09:44] Speaker B: it does feel that way.
[01:09:45] Speaker A: Yeah.
[01:09:46] Speaker C: Yeah.
But yeah, I agree that this, I mean this feels like a movie that is. And you get these movies maybe every year, at least every couple years, one of these big high profile movies that's got a great cast and everybody in it is great and the movie behind them is kind of just fine.
[01:10:06] Speaker B: Yes. Yeah.
[01:10:07] Speaker C: And it's, it's entertaining almost entirely because of the performances being given.
[01:10:12] Speaker B: Yes.
[01:10:13] Speaker C: Or like, I mean basically any David O. Russell movie, you know, it's like. Yeah,
[01:10:17] Speaker A: didn't expect to hear David O. Russell in this conversation. But I can see it though. I can definitely see.
[01:10:22] Speaker C: Yeah. I mean, very different types of movies, I guess, but.
[01:10:26] Speaker A: Because I do think the
[01:10:26] Speaker B: cast structure is the same.
[01:10:28] Speaker C: Yeah, yeah.
[01:10:30] Speaker A: I mean, yeah. Because I think Brooks is. Because Brooks adapted this. Right. Wasn't he? He adapted the screenplay.
[01:10:36] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:10:37] Speaker A: His style is, I think, little bit of a similarity to Russell but not in the same execution because Russell is problematic in a lot of different ways in terms of this kind of situation. Like Brooks, he. I think with terms I can understand why people like gravitated and grabbed on it so much as he is riding the line of having characters basically almost say to the camera and listen, I'm a character of a film. This is a coming of age drama and I'm a woman who's going through all of this. And I just need you to acknowledge that this is a thing like it's almost telling you verbatim. Like there's almost a self awareness with each one of the main characters that they are in a film and almost playing it like that. And I can understand that in his later films, if that's a little too much on the nose.
[01:11:22] Speaker B: I
[01:11:23] Speaker A: glad you off.
[01:11:24] Speaker B: I'm glad you brought that up because that was something I noticed with. I mean, so the theme from this movie was like a top 40 hit. I mean, it was so ubiquitous that it was like a instrumental score theme, you know, was being played on the radio and.
But they use it so often in the movie that it's like beaten into your head by the time it's over. But there is. You're
[01:11:46] Speaker C: sick of it before you ever hear it on the
[01:11:47] Speaker A: radio.
[01:11:48] Speaker B: Right.
There is a moment though, to the self awareness point that you brought up Logan, where Jack Nicholson and Shirley MacLaine's characters have.
They're driving his sports car in a unique arrangement on the.
On the beach.
[01:12:07] Speaker A: Yeah.
[01:12:09] Speaker B: And they get thrown into the water and they kind of have this sweet moment where they're gonna kiss and the music kind of swells up and then the music just immediately cuts out when Jack Nicholson shoves his hand down Shirley MacLaine's blouse.
And it's one of those things where it's like, it's so self aware because the music cuts out and it's just like, oh, you're watching a movie. And he punctured the moment because he can't help himself because he's just a catish, you know.
[01:12:35] Speaker A: Yeah, it's got a little. It's a little sitcom, little
[01:12:39] Speaker C: to
[01:12:39] Speaker A: a degree. I am not kidding, guys. When it fades into black and then into the credits, I cackled. I said, that's where. That's what happens. Because it almost feels like you're watching at that point. It's like. And now you've just watched a soap opera on vhs. Like, it's incredibly abrupt. And the way that it looks, it's like, what the fucking it to just end like that.
[01:13:06] Speaker B: Sure
[01:13:06] Speaker A: it is. Again, I. I do really like this movie and I do think the cast, I can see a lot through, like. Okay. I can see why people can like really love Brooks's style, especially. Honestly, when you brought up Broadcast News, Nick, I was like, fuck, yeah. That's been on my list for so long. People love that movie so much. And also Albert Brooks. No relation, I remember right to James.
Albert's in Broadcast News and apparently he plays the father who. Yeah, he's the.
[01:13:36] Speaker B: He's the voice of Rudyard. I like how
[01:13:39] Speaker A: they
[01:13:39] Speaker B: like make a point to like that his name is
[01:13:41] Speaker C: Rudyard Rudyard.
[01:13:44] Speaker A: But Like, I mean, there's little moments, again, similar to One Flew over, where it's like little moments of the cast where it's like early in the film where Shirley MacLaine's character thinks that Deborah Winger's character has died in her sleep as a baby, and then she, like, smacks the baby awake to cry that she leaves the room.
[01:14:03] Speaker C: And
[01:14:03] Speaker A: then later in the film, we're about to get that same kind of situation with Deborah Ringer, but it's almost like she has deja vu and stops herself and lets him cries and goes. Has. Goes and has sex with her cool husband named Flap.
Can I. I just like.
It's so insane because again, it being an 83 too. I bet it was a very kind of like, this is a wild thing to see in a film at all, but just like to have the cheating husband. Not true. Surprising, I think, especially early on in the film. It's, again, how this film is structured. They introduced the idea that he's cheating on Deborah Winger early on in the movie. You don't see it, but you can see in her face. She knows he's doing that, but you don't see it for another 30 minutes.
[01:14:51] Speaker B: Right.
[01:14:52] Speaker A: And then they have the conversation in the third act about how he is just not fit to be a father.
[01:15:01] Speaker B: What. What
[01:15:01] Speaker A: I think
[01:15:02] Speaker B: is interesting. Yeah. What's interesting with that is they don't reveal that. They don't reveal for certain that he's cheating until after, you know, she has also cheated.
[01:15:09] Speaker A: Yes. Which I do. I actually really liked that. That was kind of an interesting. Because you're like. All the drama there.
Maybe it's just entirely in her own head. And then, of course, no, he's. He's a piece of shit, but.
Because again, we haven't. But John Lithgow in the Care in the film is a banker who ultimately starts to have an extramarital relationship with Deborah Winger's character. And he's. He's delightful again, John Lithgow, delightful. It's.
[01:15:35] Speaker B: I love.
Yeah. I love how his pickup line is like, do you remember me? I denied you a bank loan.
Like, great,
[01:15:46] Speaker A: great. Can you help me pay for my groceries, Dude?
[01:15:48] Speaker B: Right.
[01:15:51] Speaker A: Yeah. It just, like, everyone's doing a really good job. I can understand why this movie is popular in 83. Best picture was completely shocked to find out that it was Best Picture and.
[01:16:01] Speaker C: Right.
[01:16:02] Speaker A: I just. Again, I told Andy, this. This is funny. This will. This will date the episode a little bit. But when I watch Terms of Endearment, early voting had already been Open for a while. And I early voted and decided. Okay, woke up early to early vote. You know what, let's get the rest of this trilogy out of the way. I watched Terms of Endearment and I literally finished that film. Thought it was 5:00pm Nick. I started at 11, so it was only 1:00pm like, it just felt. It literally felt like one of the longest two hour films I've seen in a while because it just like spans again. It does a good job of doing the 30 year span without feeling like overdoing with old makeup or this and that. They find little subtle ways to do it. But it does feel like you're watching 30 plus years of this relationship.
[01:16:48] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:16:49] Speaker A: In a way that. Where it's like. When you're like. And this is probably where it will go. Oh, wow. I did not expect that. Well, we're almost done, right? No, we got 20 minutes.
[01:16:58] Speaker B: Right.
[01:16:59] Speaker A: Okay. So we'll just have to.
[01:17:00] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:17:01] Speaker A: And then when it finally ends, you're like, that still doesn't even feel like that's where it should be done.
[01:17:07] Speaker B: Right.
[01:17:07] Speaker A: Okay, that's interesting.
And then we all went, God, I wish there was a sequel that everyone hated. And then literally, I think hilariously, 13, I think nearly before the final film in our trilogy, as Good as It Gets, comes out. I believe Evening Star had come.
[01:17:24] Speaker B: Yeah. It's the year before
[01:17:26] Speaker A: 96.
[01:17:27] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:17:28] Speaker A: But yeah, I think it's. I really enjoyed it. I am not surprised. Once I watched it was like, okay. I've heard people like clown on Brooks's films before in terms of like his writing style. And I can kind of. I can say it in this.
[01:17:40] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:17:41] Speaker A: But I will say, and you both could attest on the pod. When I finished watching this movie, I put in our little group chat together.
I'm terrified about how as Good as It Gets is going to be if this is the directorial debut and this is considered one of the best Brooks films out of his whole filmography.
I'm curious about the other film that got Nicholson an Oscar that is 14 years after this.
[01:18:10] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:18:11] Speaker B: And then we're going to talk about that one too.
[01:18:13] Speaker A: And it. Yeah. And that is as good as it gets. It is. It is a crazy, crazy, unhinged film.
I am going to. I need to. While I'm looking up the lineup for that year. Because the lineup for that year for Best Actor is also wild.
[01:18:33] Speaker B: Yes.
[01:18:34] Speaker A: And Best Picture for that as well. But yeah. Because by that point. Yeah. Terms of a Deermouth comes out. Broadcast news has come out. Like, Brooks has had A run for a while at this point, but I feel like he's tapered off a little bit after broadcast news.
Nicholson. Was the two Jakes already out at this point? Like, yeah, we're coming back to Chinatown. Yeah.
[01:18:55] Speaker B: Two Jake's was 1990, I believe.
[01:18:58] Speaker A: Okay.
[01:18:59] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:19:00] Speaker A: That's honestly been a side note. That's a trilogy we've had on. Yeah.
[01:19:04] Speaker C: 1990. Oh, yeah. The. The Chinatown. Yeah.
[01:19:07] Speaker A: Because who friend Roger Rabbit is rumored to be the original interstate film that never happened.
[01:19:13] Speaker B: That's funny.
[01:19:15] Speaker A: God. As Good as it Gets. Immediately the tomato rate. Tomato meter at 86%. Unhinges me.
[01:19:21] Speaker B: I
[01:19:21] Speaker A: mean, un me.
[01:19:22] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah, we'll get to that.
[01:19:25] Speaker A: We will. We will get to that.
Another thing that crazy about as Good as It Gets. A Hans Zimmer film.
[01:19:31] Speaker B: Yeah,
[01:19:32] Speaker A: he does the score. I was wondering
[01:19:34] Speaker C: if. Featuring an atrocious cover produced by Hans Zimmer and recorded by Art Garfunkel. Oh, right.
[01:19:44] Speaker B: Always look on the bright side.
[01:19:45] Speaker C: Always look on the bright side of life. Yeah.
[01:19:47] Speaker A: He didn't even think Andy Shivered,
[01:19:50] Speaker B: which. Which Jack Nicholson also performs in the movie.
[01:19:53] Speaker C: Yeah. And his version is better.
[01:19:55] Speaker B: It is better. Yeah.
[01:19:58] Speaker A: Oh, my God.
[01:19:59] Speaker C: But yeah. Okay. So, Logan, you've got the.
The lineup.
[01:20:02] Speaker A: I do, I do. Do you want me to do the lineup now, or do we want to talk about how crazy this movie is?
[01:20:07] Speaker B: Let's go with how crazy the movie is. I want
[01:20:09] Speaker A: to hear.
[01:20:09] Speaker B: When.
[01:20:09] Speaker C: I
[01:20:10] Speaker B: want to hear you go off on this.
[01:20:11] Speaker A: No, I mean, it's like. So, again, Terms of Endearment, the first Brooks film. Also Nicholson Wooding, supporting actor in that film. He is a retired astronaut and as Good as It Gets, which is not based off of a novel. I believe. It's an original script by Brooks and another. Another writer, another collaborator. He plays a severe OCD riddled romance novelist who's also a huge bigot and is just an unpleasant man to be around.
And he has a next door neighbor played by Greg Kinnear, who is a.
No one might know that he's gay or not, but Jack Nicholson makes sure in the film that, you know, he's a gay who basically is his next door neighbor with this rowdy little dog that Jack Nicholson's character. Make sure I get his name right. Yeah, Melvin Udall.
Another. Another
[01:21:12] Speaker B: hilarious name on its face.
[01:21:14] Speaker C: Yeah. But
[01:21:16] Speaker A: the film meanders for a while, and at a certain point, the painter basically gets beat to by Skeet Ulrich, Jamie Kennedy, and another guy playing a tweaker.
And he gets beat to. To a point where he can't take care of his little dog that Jack Nicholson hates. And so no one wants to take care of the dog. So it's up to Melvin to take care of it. And when Melvin takes care of the dog, it opens him up to a world he never saw before. I assume is how they sold the film in a logline esque way.
[01:21:52] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah,
[01:21:53] Speaker C: sure.
[01:21:53] Speaker A: But it is, it is. It is marketed as a rom com because another thing, I mean,
[01:22:00] Speaker C: it is,
[01:22:02] Speaker A: it is. But at the same time, when it finally gets to what's supposed to be the ROM version of the rom com, it is like Terms of Endearment very late into the film where it feels like
[01:22:13] Speaker C: it's late into the film. It's kind of a surprising turn.
[01:22:16] Speaker A: Yes.
[01:22:18] Speaker C: When it fully commits into that. I swore that I had fallen asleep at some point and missed something, but then I went back and I had not.
[01:22:26] Speaker B: No, no,
[01:22:27] Speaker A: you missed
[01:22:28] Speaker B: nothing. No,
[01:22:30] Speaker C: but yeah, it is, it is. And also I think part of it is like the first maybe half of the film almost feels like Nicholson is really kind of just like a frame, a framing device for all these other stories going on. Interesting.
The gay couple and then Greg Kinnear's character's kind of injury recovery and all of that. And everything going on with Helen Hunt's character and her kid and all of that.
And then as it shifts more into rom com mode, it becomes more centered on Nicholson's involvement in their lives and not just like, oh, he's around.
[01:23:13] Speaker A: We need to get this out of the way now because I want to hear your guys opinions on this.
The romance novelist aspect is so underutilized
[01:23:24] Speaker C: in
[01:23:24] Speaker A: a way that is fascinating. Even when it, like. Because when it gets to the point where it is becoming a rom com, it is like, oh, my God, maybe he will talk about. Because no one talks to him.
Like they know what he does. They're aware that he's rich.
[01:23:41] Speaker C: Except for the random fangirl
[01:23:42] Speaker B: right.
[01:23:43] Speaker A: At the
[01:23:43] Speaker B: publisher's office that corners him. Yeah,
[01:23:46] Speaker A: but like, they basically talk to him like, we know you're rich and you're a racist, so please go away. You're a bit of a bigot and
[01:23:55] Speaker B: a bit of a bit of a bigot.
[01:23:57] Speaker A: Well, I'm trying to be nice, Nick, if you want to. If you want to say some of the lines he says.
But it is kind of like
[01:24:05] Speaker C: it's okay. It's like school. You're just repeating what's written.
[01:24:09] Speaker B: Right.
[01:24:09] Speaker A: It's hilarious. You're
[01:24:10] Speaker C: allowed to say
[01:24:11] Speaker A: it's hilarious how this film has A character with severe OCD that also happens to be a very prominent, very successful romance novelist. And the film, I think, never says obsessive compulsive disorder. And also, doesn't
[01:24:27] Speaker C: it. Does
[01:24:27] Speaker A: it say, like. But they don't talk about his OCD as if it's the reason why he's an asshole a lot of the times, like the other characters.
[01:24:37] Speaker B: The therapist might mention it.
[01:24:39] Speaker A: Yes, the therapist, I think does. You're right. Yeah. But unfortunately, there's only one scene with him.
Right. Like, I wish there was more with that guy, but because a lot of the characters, like, are talking about how he's such a rude, horrible person. And it almost has, like, the idea of, like, do they not realize that this man has severe ocd? And also, do they know that he's, like, a beloved romance novelist? Because there's never an intent in what they're talking. There's never a feeling that they're mad at him. Because, like, your novels are so good. Why are you such a piece of shit? And there's never this feeling, which would be the obvious thing
[01:25:17] Speaker B: to do. Yeah,
[01:25:18] Speaker A: that
[01:25:18] Speaker B: would be like, the obvious scene to have is like, how are you so bad at this in real life and
[01:25:22] Speaker C: so
[01:25:22] Speaker B: good at it on the page.
[01:25:24] Speaker A: Yeah. Like, when he calls. That
[01:25:25] Speaker B: never happens
[01:25:25] Speaker A: when he calls Great Kinnear a fudge packer.
[01:25:29] Speaker C: Like,
[01:25:29] Speaker A: this Greg Kinnear is like, how is that the word you use when, like, your novels are so eloquent? Like, there's nothing that comes back at that about. Like, this guy has so much. Like, there's one scene you see him do, like his typing out, this is what the next novel is going to be. But he never talks about the novel. There's never a talk about the, like, the. The plot of it. Like, there's.
[01:25:51] Speaker C: There's never a conversation about, like, why that's what he does,
[01:25:55] Speaker A: or
[01:25:55] Speaker C: like, how how who he is informs the. The fact that that is his craft or how his craft affects his actual life. It's so interesting. And I totally agree that the romance novelist aspect is bizarrely absent from the film.
It won't be there at all. And to not use it is weird.
[01:26:17] Speaker B: Rewatching this.
So this was one of many movies that I saw in theaters in winter of 97 when. When. When Titanic was sold out and I had,
[01:26:30] Speaker A: oh, my God. Yeah.
[01:26:31] Speaker B: And I was at the movie theater. I'm like, well, I'll go see something anyway, you know. Those also included Mouse Hunt, which was unexpectedly delightful, but as Good as It Gets was one of Them, Yeah, Mouse Hunt's great.
As Good As It Gets was one of them. And it had probably been. I mean, I know I've seen it at least a couple of times, but it'd probably been, you know, 25 years at least since I had seen it last time. And what, what surprised me about it is how airless it is from like, what you expect of, like, even what you would think this movie would do. And to your point, Logan, it's like the, the third act of this movie is just like, it just kind of starts. It's kind of like Terms of Endearment. Like, it just kind of comes out of nowhere. It's like, oh, we have to drive Greg Kinnear's character to Baltimore, which they treat like it's halfway across the country when it's like five hours from New York to ask and, like, beg his parents for money. And it's just like a. And it's like, oh, you need to come with me because I can't go on a trip alone with a gay man. And it's just a. And even the whole third act, like, even, like you said, like the romantic element of it in that, like, there's a weird, like, they prolong it further. When he thinks like, oh, well, maybe you could sleep with him and cure him of his homeless. I was like, what is happening? That doesn't even seem like something he would say.
[01:28:01] Speaker C: No, yeah.
[01:28:02] Speaker A: No, it also, to clarify, because I want to also address this out up in front with this, the rom com aspect, the relationship the movie is pushing hard is Helen Hunt and Jack Nicholson. Helen Hunt in the film. She won an Oscar as well, correctly?
[01:28:21] Speaker B: She did,
[01:28:22] Speaker C: yeah.
[01:28:22] Speaker A: Actually,
[01:28:23] Speaker C: I think only the seventh time that the same movie has had best actor and best actress win in one
[01:28:30] Speaker A: year. And I, I think Helen Hut does a good job with what she's given. She's a lot of fun, if anything. She's fun. She's fun in the movie.
I can give the main cast credit for having a fun time. And then sometimes that comes through the screen and I'm also having a fun time. But Jack Nicholson is born. Was born in 1937. So by the time this movie is coming out, he is 60, 59, when they probably shot it. Helen Hunt was born in 1963, so she is 30. 33. 34.
[01:29:06] Speaker C: 33. Yeah.
[01:29:07] Speaker A: When this movie's come out. So this movie is pushing past a Tom Cruise esque gap between these love interests in a way.
And
[01:29:16] Speaker C: Jack Nicholson at 60 does not look like Tom Cruise.
[01:29:20] Speaker A: No, no, no. No, no, it is very much like when you see Jackson,
[01:29:23] Speaker C: you don't even have that
[01:29:25] Speaker A: to
[01:29:25] Speaker C: hide behind.
[01:29:25] Speaker A: You're like, that's what Jack Nicholson looks in my head. This is what I think. Jack Nicholson.
[01:29:31] Speaker B: I will give the movie a little bit of credit. They do address that. It would be a little creepy for this to happen.
[01:29:40] Speaker A: Yeah.
[01:29:40] Speaker B: Even though it does happen. Like there's the whole, the whole turn, like with, you know, how he assists her and her son and you know, the immediate assumption is that he's doing this to get sex. And I mean, I think that's actually a good scene in the movie where she confronts him about that and he's kind of like the weird thing is like, it's almost like. Well, I wasn't really thinking about it that way. But now that you bring it up, like, yeah, like that might be
[01:30:05] Speaker A: my
[01:30:05] Speaker B: mission for the third act of the movie. Right.
[01:30:08] Speaker A: Well, it's also, again, I feel like if it was. I will give Brooks this. If it was a lesser director.
She comes into that scene with a wet T shirt and her nipples clearly showing.
[01:30:21] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:30:21] Speaker A: And I thought
[01:30:22] Speaker C: some quintessential 90s rain soaked t shirt.
[01:30:26] Speaker A: And
[01:30:26] Speaker C: I
[01:30:27] Speaker A: thought we were gonna get a whole scene where she was gonna do that talk. And Nicholson could not help but look the entire.
[01:30:34] Speaker C: Right, right.
[01:30:35] Speaker A: And then he's. Then she's like, oh, you pig. And then he's like, sorry, I can see your nipples. Like I thought that was. But the fact that before he opens the door, she realizes and goes, oh. And then like has this weird pose. Right. Really goofy, but fun. Like I have. I'll give Brooks, I'll give him a brownie point. I'll give him a gold star sticker for that. Cuz that was a nice little thing that. Yeah. And then once that happens, he's like, oh, so you don't have sex with. Meanwhile, I do want to have sex with you. Fuck. You make a good point. I didn't even think about that.
[01:31:06] Speaker B: And I mean, I like this movie.
It's got more problems than I remembered it having because I mean, I remember finding him funny. I remember like. And I do still like the notion that there's not a.
There is and there isn't like, there's not like a buttoned in formula that this movie's gonna take. Like one other thing that it throws in very late is Greg Kinnear moving in with Jack Nicholson, which. Which in a. Which in a movie like that would have been. You know, I think if you made that movie now, you wouldn't have the romantic element of it, at least not in the sense you do here. It would be an odd couple thing about, you know, a gay artist and out. A proudly out gay artist moving in with a tremendous bigot because he has nowhere else to go, you know, but that happens so late in the movie that it's like. I mean, it's literally like 15 minutes left in the movie that Greg Kinnear moves in. Yeah. And that's the end of like their story, those two characters. Story.
[01:32:15] Speaker A: Yeah. There's definitely using the fact that that Kinnear, who again, I think Kinnear. One thing I give the movie credit to get. I do.
I think this movie's fine. I do like them.
But I will say that, like, if anything, one thing I do like, I think the two main gay characters in the film are played by Greg Kinnear and Cuba Gooding Jr.
[01:32:38] Speaker B: Right.
[01:32:38] Speaker A: A fascinating duo alone on that being the gay couple in this film. And they are not.
They are putting, you know, effort into the characters to have, like, they're not full blown stereotypes. They're having little affections. Kinir is definitely doing a little bit more of like. I guess you can consider that a stereotype. But Kinnear, I think, is giving a lot of love and trying not to come off as a cartoon character.
But with Cuba, I love the fact that he's just being himself. It just feels very much like Cuba Gooden Jr. Is being the protective boyfriend of this. Of this couple. And because I was when I saw Cuba Gooding Jr. Because again, this cast is also kind of crazy.
[01:33:21] Speaker B: Yeah,
[01:33:21] Speaker A: it's got talent across the belt. I mean, with Nicholson, Hunt, Kinnear, Cuba Gooding Jr. I said skeet Ulrich, he's a small part in this film. I thought he would come back and they would catch him. When they beats up Kinir, they never do.
Shirley Knight, who plays Helen Hunt's mom and is also a single year older than Jack Nicholson.
[01:33:42] Speaker B: Correct. I looked that up because I'm like, she's got to be his. His peer.
[01:33:47] Speaker A: You also have side characters with Brian Doyle Murray, Missy Pyle. Shane Black is the head of the coffee shop restaurant Jack Nicholson gets kicked out of. Apparently Maya Rudolph is also in the film.
[01:34:03] Speaker C: Yeah. Yep. Harold Ramos,
[01:34:05] Speaker A: Lawrence Kasdan, Harold Ramis. But I will say, of course,
[01:34:08] Speaker B: Wood Harris from the Wire.
[01:34:12] Speaker C: Yeah, yeah.
[01:34:12] Speaker B: Without Wood Harris's character, the movie doesn't happen because that's how Melvin gets the phone number, gets her last name.
[01:34:20] Speaker A: But I will say I would be not surprised if you were in the crowd in 97. And it was probably device like, divided between one half seeing this woman being like, why is she in so many scenes with Greg Kinnear? And then the other half going, oh, that's Lisa Simpson. Which is your Lisa
[01:34:39] Speaker B: Smith. Yes.
[01:34:40] Speaker A: As Kinnear's agents. Which is like, okay, there we go. Got the Simpsons connection
[01:34:45] Speaker C: there.
[01:34:46] Speaker A: And she's very sweet, and she's got a funny. She's got one funny scene in particular where it's the whole, I need post. I need cards.
Oh, yeah. To break bad
[01:34:56] Speaker B: news.
[01:34:59] Speaker A: Yeah, It's. It's. It's just like.
It's wild to me that this one best act like it had any Oscars attached to it. But at the same time, I will say not. That's not because Nicholson's doing a bad job. One of the funniest things about this film isn't even about the content of the film. It's the fact that you can clearly tell that apparently rumor has it that when they were making this film, at one point, they had to shut down production for two weeks because Nicholson put so much effort into trying to accurately depict someone with severe OCD that it just clashed with what Brooks wanted OCD to be in the film and just couldn't figure out an in between until they both stopped production for two weeks and talked it out. And once I saw that, if it's genuinely true, I feel like now anytime I watch the film, I will just see Nicholson's performance as a man who's trying his best to be accurate, engaging, and actually give, like, not make OCD a gimmick or a stereotype in this film, but also clashing with James O. Brooks being like, you have ocd. It's funny. Like, do this thing, and it's like this classic clashing of, like, the director and actor having different ideas of what this character should be on screen.
[01:36:20] Speaker B: I do think that. I'm glad you brought that up, because I do think that that's one thing that the movie does really well that I had. You know, I mean, I knew he was an OCD character, but I had forgotten the. The specifics that they, you know, expressed that with.
The first time you see him expressing it, you know, he goes into his apartment, he does the multiple. Multiple
[01:36:40] Speaker C: locking
[01:36:41] Speaker B: and the light switch, and then he does. He's washing his hands, and he
[01:36:45] Speaker A: has,
[01:36:46] Speaker B: like, dozens of
[01:36:47] Speaker C: Neutrogena soap bars.
[01:36:49] Speaker B: He's scalding his hands, and he's using the soap bar for about five seconds and then throwing it away and getting another one.
[01:36:56] Speaker C: And the
[01:36:56] Speaker B: scene goes on just long enough that you're like, this is really sad. Like, this isn't funny. Like, and there's really only kind of one joke moment where they kind of like, make the ocd, like, into a punchline. And when he's going to his therapist's office and he's like, he won't step on cracks in the sidewalk, and he says, it's the worst sidewalk in New York. And they put it here, which admittedly, at that point, you know well enough the scope of who he is and what's afflicting him, that it is kind of funny. But they don't. They don't joke about him. He is not the punchline for having ocd.
[01:37:39] Speaker A: No, you go
[01:37:41] Speaker C: ahead.
I agree, Nick. And I think one of the other things I love about him in this movie, I, you know, I agree with Logan. It's not a movie that I think that I would think of as, you know, his Oscar. One of his Oscar wins amongst his career.
It's a solid performance, and I respect that he put so much effort into it. But it's interesting to hear that about his conflict with Patterson. No, Brooks.
[01:38:14] Speaker B: Yeah,
[01:38:15] Speaker C: Brooks. Yeah, Patterson.
[01:38:17] Speaker B: James Patterson versus
[01:38:18] Speaker C: Patterson.
[01:38:18] Speaker B: As good as it Gets would be pretty interesting, though.
[01:38:22] Speaker C: But, yeah, like, their conflict over that is interesting to me because the way it read to me, Nat Nicholson as an OCD person was like, oh, this is brilliant. Because a director has finally, like, leveraged one of Nicholson's, like, trademark things as an actor to be something other than just like Nicholson being his Nicholson self. And what I mean by that is Nicholson does this thing in almost all of his movies where, like, the way he responds to someone, like, the other character will have, you know, their big moment or this big outburst or like an accusation or something, and he just. Either he sits there, maybe he kind of purses his lips, and he either stares back at them or stares off into the distance, like, almost through his eyelids, like he's kind of just waking up. And it's this. He. He's usually using it as, like, his wind up to. To get him back with his zinger or whatever.
And he does that all the time in this. But the way it reads, because he's an OCD character is like, oh, this is a guy who thinks differently, who's trying to understand why what he does pisses people off.
[01:39:39] Speaker B: Right?
[01:39:39] Speaker A: Yeah.
[01:39:39] Speaker C: And he's not necessarily, you know, a great guy about it or, like, trying to do better, but he's clearly there's a disconnect and he's just not getting it. And that's him, like, processing how to respond. But it's just so interesting because it's like. It's just a. It's just a trademark Nicholson thing. It's not, like, a choice he's making differently from his other movies, but the way it works in the film is like, oh, okay. That. It's the. It's the only time I've seen where kind of that trademark of his feels like it's leveraged purposefully for a specific quirk of the character.
And I thought that was really cool.
[01:40:18] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:40:19] Speaker A: Oh, yeah. I mean, again, I don't. I don't think Nicholson is playing his Care Melvin up for laughs in a way that feels disingenuous to the reality of ocd and the way that it's finding a way to make it funny in context where it's like, this is just kind of funny in general because it's like the one time, I think, when Helen Hunt's not at the restaurant, and he pulls out his little Ziploc bag of plastic forks,
[01:40:45] Speaker B: right?
[01:40:46] Speaker A: Like his utensils. And then this random blonde girl comes up and is like, why do you have this? This is weird. And just grabs it. And the way that Nicholson looks like he's about to just explode, it's like, listen, even if, like, I don't have ocd, but I would also hate if I brought in my own utensils and someone started touching them. I was like, quit it.
So it's like, to have him again, it is very much like, yeah, OCD is not like, the punchline. It is mostly just like it is. Honestly, some of the best punchlines in the film is seeing what his quirks are and the things that he has to do in order to make his brain make sense. Like, the big thing being the type of sidewalks he walks on, because it's not even just cracks. It's also. He doesn't like bricks,
[01:41:27] Speaker B: right?
[01:41:27] Speaker A: Or it's like bricks or like, stone. Because, like, a big thing later on is that he. He can't wear used clothing. He has to be new, where he has to wash it himself. And so they go to this nice restaurant, they offer him a jacket, and it's like Helen Hunt's like, oh, maybe they watch this every so often. And, like, oh, we haven't touched this in a while. Which is a funny bit.
And then Nicholson runs away, drives to the nearest suit store, and then can't go inside because the floor is patterned in a way that he just can't handle It. And so he's just awkwardly, like, he's moving his body in a way like he can't push through a force field to get in, but also doesn't want to get in because he wants to. To see all the suits. He's just like, that one. Give me that one. I don't care if it fits. Give me that. And it's just like, okay, that's fun. The movie is fun. It's just the fact that, like, in that Brooks fashion, we. Nick brought it up and we talked about with terms where it's like that third act feels like, oh, we're going this way now. This is where we're going now.
[01:42:24] Speaker B: Right.
[01:42:24] Speaker A: As good as it gets. I think it's even worse with that when it decides to go, oh, the third act now is that the gay artist is broken and he's too afraid to talk to his parents. And now we got to do, like you said, a road trip. Because his boyfriend, who clearly is like, oh, I love, I love Simon, but I have too much with my job, but I can't support him right now. Yeah.
Cuba Goody
[01:42:47] Speaker B: Jr. Is like, purely like, like, he shows up to, like, move the movie into, like, the, the subsequent acts. Like, that's his only function. Yeah. Like, you get nothing. You get nothing of their life together. You get nothing of their.
And it's. Yeah. It's literally like, I can't do this. You need to do it. And it's like, oh, okay, well, now we get all three of these disparate characters together for a road trip. Yeah.
[01:43:13] Speaker A: And it is again, it might just also because Cuba Goodyen Jr. Was Cuba Gooding Jr. In the late 90s and just had a bunch of other things he was doing and wanted to be in a James L. Brooks.
[01:43:22] Speaker B: I mean, that's possible.
I, I think, Andy, I, I, I'm really. It's. This was something that, like, I didn't think about as actively when watching it, but. And Logan, you brought it up, too. I mean, I, I think there are, like, more subtle things going on here with what he's doing. Like, he's not, like you said, it's not a new trick, but it's a new application of the trick.
[01:43:49] Speaker A: Yeah.
[01:43:49] Speaker B: And, and, you know, maybe in a year where I think maybe Matt Damon was, like, maybe I would say, his most. His strongest competition in the category, like, that's maybe something like, you know, old dog, new. Ish trick that, that stood out for people.
Yeah.
Yeah. But
[01:44:13] Speaker A: also
[01:44:13] Speaker B: here, also a year where Leonardo DiCaprio was not nominated for Titanic, which was weird then. And frankly, like. Like, if that movie came out now, like, he would have been nominated. And he had been nominated before. I mean, he was. I mean, he was already an Oscar nominee at that point, which was.
So.
[01:44:28] Speaker A: Yeah, I guess we'll just get out of the way now because you've already alluded to it, and it is kind of fascinating to look at it now. The year that Nicholson won for this film, the best actor nominees were Robert Duvall in the Apostle, Peter Fonda in Ulysse's Gold because he played Ulysses Jackson, Dustin Hoffman, Stanley Motts in Wag the Dog, and then, of course, Matt Damon in a little niche film you might have heard called Good Will Hunting. As Will Hunting.
[01:44:55] Speaker B: Right.
[01:44:56] Speaker A: His biggest. And arguably, I would. I would say, even with how it is, I understand Damon not necessarily winning for this role, even though this is his film and this is a great. It's. He's a great performance in that movie. I do think Damon gets more.
It does have the energy of, like, you're great now, kid, but we'll see you down the line and we'll just like.
[01:45:16] Speaker C: Yeah. I mean, it's a movie that the. The script really leads.
[01:45:20] Speaker A: Yes, they won the Oscar for that.
[01:45:22] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:45:23] Speaker B: But of those five, I. I would still give it to Damon. I mean, I think
[01:45:30] Speaker A: fair,
[01:45:31] Speaker B: you know, I mean, I like this performance. I like this movie. I liked it maybe a little bit less than. Than in my memory, you know, from 25 years ago. I do think it's entirely too long. I do think it doesn't.
It just seems to drift for 20 minutes past where it could.
[01:45:49] Speaker A: The twist of the film being Simon doesn't have to see his parents
[01:45:53] Speaker B: actually
[01:45:53] Speaker A: kind of pissed me off. I was like, why
[01:45:56] Speaker C: are we doing that?
[01:45:56] Speaker A: You're building up so much. And all he needed was to see naked Helen Hunt to be there.
[01:46:01] Speaker B: Right.
[01:46:04] Speaker C: Speaking of Simon, just while we're on a little bit of a science thing, I.
I don't understand why Greg Kinnear was nominated.
[01:46:12] Speaker B: I think that was
[01:46:13] Speaker C: supporting.
[01:46:14] Speaker B: I think that was much in the way that maybe. I mean, although he didn't win, obviously much.
I mean, that was. That was Robin Williams Award to lose.
[01:46:24] Speaker C: Sure.
[01:46:24] Speaker B: Across the board. And I mean, that's. That's a justified win to me.
[01:46:28] Speaker C: Yeah, absolutely.
[01:46:29] Speaker B: I think. I think Kinnear was like. It was kind of swept
[01:46:33] Speaker C: up in
[01:46:34] Speaker B: the. It was kind of swept up in. I think, like, just, you know, the movie is about all three of them and Kinnear. I think Kinnear in A way, in a different way was kind of like Damon, where he'd been. People knew him from talk soup and this snarky, you know, you know, self aware commentary on tv and, you know, he'd made a, you know, a credible transition into dramatic acting, although it wasn't his first attempt. He did a movie called Dear God the previous year, which is not unlike the Postman where he starts answering people's letters addressed to God. It's a terrible movie.
[01:47:15] Speaker A: I will say at least Wikipedia could be entirely wrong on this, but I'll look at the sources later. Apparently again, Kinnear was not the first choice.
[01:47:25] Speaker B: Okay.
[01:47:26] Speaker A: The first two people that least Wikipedia brings up as the notable.
No, Geoffrey Rush was apparently flown in to read Interesting. He declined it. And then apparently Shalhoub, Tony Shalhoub, thought that could be an interesting role.
[01:47:42] Speaker B: And
[01:47:42] Speaker A: then also was like, no, it went to Kinnear. Like
[01:47:46] Speaker B: those are two completely different.
I mean, those would each be completely different in their own way than they are
[01:47:54] Speaker C: different from
[01:47:55] Speaker B: Kinnear.
[01:47:55] Speaker A: Also, in case you didn't know, this is apparently ranked 140th on Empire's 500 Greatest Movies of all time list.
[01:48:03] Speaker B: As good as it gets.
[01:48:04] Speaker A: Yes, 140, apparently.
[01:48:06] Speaker B: Come on.
[01:48:08] Speaker A: Another thing. What are
[01:48:09] Speaker C: we doing?
[01:48:09] Speaker A: Because I didn't realize, I think this is also accurate, but James Brooks is also known for apparently being one of the first people to open the door for the Wilson brothers. And apparently one of the first jobs. Wilson. Yeah.
And then one of the first jobs that Owen Wilson had apparently was being an associate producer on this movie.
[01:48:29] Speaker B: What?
[01:48:30] Speaker A: Apparently I'm gonna double check on IMDb but because I knew about the fact that Brooks was like one of the first people to be like, hey, these Wilson brothers have something. And so like Anderson and the Bottle Rocket and all that. But like, yeah, if that's true, that's crazy. If that Wilson did with producer
[01:48:48] Speaker B: Wild,
[01:48:49] Speaker A: I'm going to double check that. But.
[01:48:50] Speaker B: But yeah, I do think. I mean, so while you're looking that up, I will tell you, I think Nicholson should have three.
I think the third one. And here's where we get to Sean Penn.
[01:49:05] Speaker C: Do you think he should have three Oscars?
[01:49:07] Speaker B: He should have three Oscars. I think two of them are for the wrong thing.
He wasn't even nominated in this year. And I bring up Sean Pennsylvania because Sean Penn in I Am Sam,
[01:49:19] Speaker A: I knew this was what it's gonna be.
[01:49:22] Speaker B: In addition to being mocked in Tropic Thunder, appropriately is legitimately one of the most embarrassing Oscar nominations. In the history of the whole enterprise.
[01:49:33] Speaker C: The whole thing. Yeah.
[01:49:35] Speaker B: That movie is actively offensive to a point where when he got nominated, I was just like, what are we even doing here? I mean, I know that, you know, there were obviously other better nominees that year, and he wasn't going to contend for it, but in 2001.
And Sean Penn and Jack Nicholson are friends. They've worked together on several things.
Jack Nicholson did a movie in 2001 called the Pledge.
[01:50:07] Speaker C: Yeah.
[01:50:07] Speaker B: That
[01:50:08] Speaker C: I knew you were going to mention
[01:50:09] Speaker B: because I've talked to you about this on Jack. Sure. I don't shut up about this movie. Pretty much, like, anytime I bring it
[01:50:14] Speaker C: up, I watched it because.
[01:50:17] Speaker B: Just a terrific folding in of all of the brash and confident things you expect about Jack Nicholson.
[01:50:31] Speaker C: And
[01:50:31] Speaker B: he did that also in About Schmidt, which is also a great performance. And he was Oscar nominated for that.
Did not win in 2002.
But the pledge, the Pledge is so.
It's just devastating. Like, you are, and you're devastated because of how utterly ruined his character is by the end of that movie. And I don't want to spoil. Why
[01:50:55] Speaker A: I'll have to add to my list. I forgot the Pledge. I don't think you've had your whole spiel with me
[01:51:00] Speaker C: about downer. It
[01:51:01] Speaker B: is.
You will be depressed.
You will be amazed at how many. Well, Sean Penn directed it. Sean Penn directed the Pledge.
[01:51:09] Speaker A: Okay.
[01:51:10] Speaker B: You will be amazed at how many people are in it for about two minutes.
Like, how many huge names are in it for about two minutes.
And just a terrific performance. And I think he. You know, I think he should have won it for that. I mean, it's one. It's easy to say, like, oh, well, yeah, he wasn't even nominated for it. I just. I think he should have been nominated for that.
[01:51:32] Speaker C: Yeah. Yeah.
[01:51:33] Speaker B: And wanted for that.
So.
[01:51:36] Speaker C: Well, you've. You've.
[01:51:39] Speaker B: Did I give Logan enough time to look up what. What you were looking up?
[01:51:43] Speaker A: Oh, I. Yeah. Wilson was an associate producer.
[01:51:45] Speaker B: Okay. That is. That is crazy. I had no idea
[01:51:49] Speaker A: he might be one of the only associate producers. Oh, wow. Because there's a lot of people that produce the film. But I think he's. Yeah. But while we're on the topic, because, again, I think. Because another thing that's fascinating about as Good as it Gets now is that when people. When you talk to people and talk to people about this episode that we're doing and they're like, oh, Nicholson winning three Oscars. That makes sense. And I think most people's thought is, well, one of those is for the Departed, right?
[01:52:15] Speaker B: Yeah. Right.
[01:52:17] Speaker A: Because it's like when people think of a Nicholson film, that's like the last Nicholson film, I think a lot of people think about being such a big deal because that movie was won an Oscar and nominated.
[01:52:27] Speaker C: I mean, here's a fun fact. It's his second highest rated film.
[01:52:31] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:52:32] Speaker A: I mean, he's great.
[01:52:33] Speaker C: I mean, granted, there's a lot of other stuff going on now that him.
[01:52:37] Speaker B: That supporting actor Oscar nomination had to go to Mark Wahlberg, guys. I mean, come
[01:52:41] Speaker C: on.
[01:52:42] Speaker A: God bless.
[01:52:43] Speaker C: Yeah. It's his best role.
[01:52:45] Speaker A: He was just out from Ash Wednesday. They had to give it to you.
But just so. Because we're talking now, now that I have the list up of all the other Oscar noms that he's had over the years, it'd be fun to talk about the first Oscar again to show Nicholson's breadth in his filmography and the actors, like, what he's done in his life. His first Oscar nominee was a supporting actor role in Easy Rider. That was his first nominee.
[01:53:14] Speaker C: 69.
[01:53:14] Speaker A: Yep. And then the next year, Five Easy Pieces, which Nick's already brought up. And then three years later, the Last Detail for best actor in a leading role. And then a year after that, it's 73, 74, 75 is last detail.
Chinatown. And then he finally wins the first time. And One Flew
[01:53:32] Speaker B: Over.
[01:53:33] Speaker A: And then he got nominated for reds.
[01:53:37] Speaker B: A six year gap. I mean,
[01:53:39] Speaker C: 81.
[01:53:40] Speaker A: Yes. And then one supported for terms.
And then two years after he was nominated for Prizzy's Honor.
[01:53:47] Speaker B: Right.
[01:53:47] Speaker A: In a leading role. And then also a film I genuinely have not heard of before, Ironweed
[01:53:53] Speaker B: I actually
[01:53:53] Speaker A: nominated.
[01:53:54] Speaker B: Yeah,
[01:53:54] Speaker C: I hadn't heard of Prizzies either.
[01:53:57] Speaker B: So I actually watched Ironweed for the first time. We did a Meryl Streep series, and I watched the movies of hers that I had not seen for which she had also been Oscar nominated. And that's also not a very uplifting movie.
It's about two incredibly alcoholic people in kind of like a spiral of despair.
They're both good in it. Yeah,
[01:54:27] Speaker A: I'm just. I'm just reading now that Kevin Hart's doing a remake of Prizzy's Honor for now.
[01:54:32] Speaker B: What?
[01:54:33] Speaker C: Dwayne Johnson.
[01:54:34] Speaker B: I
[01:54:34] Speaker A: thought. I
[01:54:35] Speaker B: thought you were. I thought you say Kevin Hart was doing a remake of Iron. We
[01:54:40] Speaker C: know Iron Weed is the one with him and Dwayne Johnson. Yeah.
[01:54:43] Speaker A: They're giving him $60 million not to do the films, really? Just because they wanted to give him money.
But of course, the. The Other two films you brought up about Schmidt, that's the last time we got nominee, which is crazy. The other film that I think some. Most people would assume would be his last Oscar win is 92's a few good Men because. Yes. That's, of course, one of the most iconic scenes. Right.
[01:55:08] Speaker C: You can't handle the truth being his clip.
[01:55:11] Speaker A: Yeah, absolutely. Which, again, that's a great question, too. What's this clip for as Good As It Gets. Because they're clearly worth glyphs at that time.
[01:55:19] Speaker B: It.
So I'm pretty sure the clip for as Good As It Gets is the. You make me want to be a better man. That.
[01:55:26] Speaker C: Yeah, it's gotta be that
[01:55:27] Speaker B: whole thing.
[01:55:28] Speaker A: Yeah. It comes in five minutes before the credits. We're just gonna get that scene.
[01:55:32] Speaker B: It's a little bit. No,
[01:55:33] Speaker C: yeah, there's. It's earlier
[01:55:35] Speaker B: than. It's earlier than that.
[01:55:36] Speaker C: Yeah. Because he still has to do the thing where he. He ruins his chance at the relationship. That's right. After that.
[01:55:42] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah,
[01:55:42] Speaker C: yeah. Right.
[01:55:43] Speaker A: The amount of times it's on,
[01:55:45] Speaker C: off.
[01:55:46] Speaker A: Yeah,
[01:55:46] Speaker C: yeah,
[01:55:47] Speaker A: yeah.
[01:55:47] Speaker C: Very suddenly on, and then we're calling it off.
[01:55:50] Speaker A: I like
[01:55:50] Speaker B: how. I like how they also never explain medically what they figure out about her son.
[01:55:56] Speaker A: It's movie.
[01:55:57] Speaker C: Oh, yeah.
[01:55:58] Speaker A: It's.
[01:55:59] Speaker C: Yeah,
[01:55:59] Speaker B: that's right. It is
[01:56:00] Speaker A: really
[01:56:01] Speaker B: bad. It
[01:56:01] Speaker A: was funny. It was funny as someone with asthma for the majority of his life watching the movie, being like, what is this kid? He's, like, throwing up, apparently, and,
[01:56:09] Speaker C: yeah,
[01:56:10] Speaker A: he can barely breathe. It can't be. And then it's like, no, he's got asthma, like, bad. And it's like, that's crazy. That's.
[01:56:17] Speaker B: Yeah.
[01:56:17] Speaker A: Then again, I was a kid that had to do breathing treatments growing up, but I don't remember ever having asthma like that. So I was like, oh, I guess it's just movie asthma. Yeah, more or
[01:56:27] Speaker B: less.
[01:56:27] Speaker A: And as soon as Harold Ramis comes into his life, everything's fine.
[01:56:30] Speaker B: Right.
[01:56:31] Speaker A: He's playing soccer games, he's running around.
The meds were just wrong. It was wild. How this movie's like. It's crazy how this film also feels like it is commenting on how up the healthcare system is in 1997. Yeah.
The fact that the only way they can help their child is through a rich man who wants to fuck Helen.
[01:56:51] Speaker B: Right. So you brought up 92 for a few Good Men. I mean. And, I mean, that was Gene Hackman's year for Unforgiven, correct? Yeah.
[01:57:00] Speaker A: I mean, so that's.
[01:57:02] Speaker B: That's a tough you know, I think they made the right call. I mean, Gene Hackman, I think is better in Unforgiven. I mean, Jack Nicholson's great for what they need him to do in A Few Good Men, but it's like it's basically to just be Jack Nicholson and, you know, scream at Tom Cruise.
[01:57:18] Speaker C: Yeah, right, right.
[01:57:19] Speaker B: But yeah, that's a great point that you would think if he had a supporting actor Oscar, if you just asked somebody point blank which movie that was for, they would probably say that.
[01:57:27] Speaker A: Yeah. And for 93. Because 93 would be the year that A Few Good Men would get nominated for best actor.
Hanks won for Philadelphia. But that list was like.
[01:57:38] Speaker B: Was A few good men 93 or 92?
[01:57:41] Speaker A: 92. But 2. But
[01:57:42] Speaker C: the Oscars.
[01:57:45] Speaker A: And of course, 92.
The Al Pacino won for Son of a Woman.
[01:57:49] Speaker B: Yes.
[01:57:50] Speaker A: So it's the excellent.
[01:57:51] Speaker B: The excellent,
[01:57:52] Speaker A: yes.
[01:57:54] Speaker B: The schmaltzy is all hell, but still excellent. Son of a woman.
[01:57:57] Speaker A: God, 93. Tom Hanks, Daniel Day Lewis, Lawrence Fish. Fishburne. Anthony Hopkins. Anthony Hopkins post Silence of Lambs. And then the last of that group is Liam Neeson as Oscar Schindler. Right. Schindler's List. And Tom Hanks won for Philadelphia. What a fucking lineup. And then Tom wins the next year
[01:58:15] Speaker B: for.
Yeah,
[01:58:16] Speaker A: yeah.
And then of course, God, that's Morgan, Nigel Hawthorne, Paul Newman, John Travolta and Pulp Fiction. Yep.
God, these lineups are crazy.
Jeffrey Rush got a nomination the year prior for Shine.
[01:58:31] Speaker B: Right?
Well, he was, didn't he? Yeah,
[01:58:34] Speaker A: yeah, he won. He won. Yeah. And then, God, Sling Blade the year before. It's like one of those things where this years go by and you. There's some films that just feel like, oh, that came out 40 years ago. And I was like, no, honestly, that film was not that far, long ago. And also it was literally sandwiched between all these other bangers at the same time.
[01:58:54] Speaker B: Yeah,
[01:58:54] Speaker A: it's like, damn. Okay.
But yeah, I mean, yeah, I do agree that like there it's. This isn't something where Nicholson won just because it was Nicholson. It's clearly a part of what's why. But it is like seeing what he does in the performance as well as like, he doesn't have like, he clearly is doing this film because he likes working with Brooks, because he also. Because he shows up in broadcast news for a little bit too. He
[01:59:22] Speaker B: does. And he
[01:59:23] Speaker A: has a good relationship.
[01:59:24] Speaker B: Yeah. He's also in how do you know? Which as of now is his last movie.
[01:59:29] Speaker A: And so it's. I mean, he's just he has a good relationship with Brooks and clearly there's something here that he really latched on to. And I think even if Brooks and Nicholson had some clash in terms of which way tonally to go, clearly Brooks let Nicholson work in a way that was enough for him to get the Oscar. And I would agree with you too, Nick. While I do think there is an energy of like, you know, Damon is phenomenal and Google hunting when we're to give it a Jack. I would give it to Damon if it was my choice. That also feels like the coldest take in the world because of all these films that are, like, being nominated for this. Like, because Damon's. Of course Damon has to be. It's not your fault.
[02:00:08] Speaker B: Right.
[02:00:08] Speaker A: Which is. Or it's Robin. Robin and Damon should be the same clip. Yeah.
No, because Robbins has to be the park.
It has to be. You don't know what love is.
[02:00:18] Speaker B: Right.
[02:00:20] Speaker A: And then. And
[02:00:21] Speaker B: that's a. Yeah, that's the thing where, like, I think those two, like, you can't.
It's weird to not honor one of those performances without the other. And it's weird that, like, the two performances that were like, from the same movie were Jack Nicholson and Helen Hunt in this. It's like.
[02:00:37] Speaker C: Right.
[02:00:38] Speaker B: It's just a weird disconnect to.
You know, I've always felt that way. And I do. I do, like, as good as it gets. I love Goodwill hunting, but I. But I also get why, like, coronating Matt Damon may. I mean, there's all sorts of politics that go into the award. Right. As opposed to
[02:00:57] Speaker A: the
[02:00:58] Speaker B: actual best performance, like, coronating Matt Damon that early may not have been something that they wanted to do.
[02:01:04] Speaker A: Yeah, it's a lot of that. It definitely does seem. It seems with just historically, a lot of the times for the Academy just getting a nomination can sometimes be in their heads enough for a movie to be like, see, you're part of one of the crew now. You've got a nomination.
[02:01:18] Speaker C: You're in.
[02:01:19] Speaker A: You were never gonna win in our heads, but at least people now will call you the Oscar nominated film or actor.
Another thing I need to bring up. I told Andy about this. I had no idea that this was about as good as it gets. But I love this story where Robin Williams is on Graham Norton talking about winning for Goodwill hunting. And of course, Williams wins first and then Nicholson wins later. And apparently when Nicholson won, he went off stage and he saw Robin and said, you know what, Robbo? Now I have one for every decade.
And it's Like Williams is like, you bastard.
You cocky son of a. You literally have an Oscar for three different decades.
And it's. It's. Yeah, this is thing about. Yeah,
[02:02:04] Speaker C: well, Nick, a minute ago, you preempted my stinger question that I wanted to give. No, it's okay. I very much appreciated your spiel on the Pledge.
But we now know one, or actually maybe two of what you would pick.
As Nicholson's three Oscars were up to you, I assume one flu remains in his three. Yeah.
[02:02:29] Speaker B: So my three would be One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest. I think of the three that we've talked about, I think that's the one. Like. Yes, I would say that is a choice that was made. That was the right choice. I would say the supporting one should be for Reds from 1981. And then I would say the third actor, even though he wasn't nominated, should be for the Pledge. But if we're talking about things for which he was nominated and didn't win, I also love about Schmidt.
I think that would have been also a great choice. And frankly, I think he probably didn't win that because as Good as It Gets was so recent. I mean, it was only five years before that, and that was the year Adrien Brody won, which was its own surprise with him. I think he was the youngest person at the time, I think, to have won Best Actor. I think that that is the case.
So.
So if we're going any three performances, I would say Cuckoo's Nest, Reds.
[02:03:37] Speaker C: We lost. Nick,
[02:03:38] Speaker B: you lost me.
[02:03:40] Speaker C: I think I did. Did Logan. Did you lose.
[02:03:42] Speaker A: I didn't lose him. He's right.
[02:03:43] Speaker C: Oh, then it was me. The problem was me.
[02:03:45] Speaker A: It's all good. It's fine. I'm not going to cut this out. Don't worry about it. Okay.
[02:03:50] Speaker C: Continue, Nick.
[02:03:50] Speaker A: Yeah,
[02:03:51] Speaker B: so if I were picking the three that overall I think he should have won for, it would be Cuckoo's Nest, Reds, and the. And the Pledge. If we're swabbing, you know, subbing in. Okay. It has to be something he was nominated for. I would say about Schmidt instead of the Pledge. Yeah. But I do.
What. What are you guys, like, if you. If you had to pick, like.
[02:04:10] Speaker C: Yeah, Logan.
[02:04:11] Speaker B: Yeah,
[02:04:11] Speaker A: I was. I'm looking right now. I do think if we are sticking with films that he actually got nominated for, I have a soft spot for Chinatown. I think he's phenomenal in that film. And honestly, for what? In terms of nominations, I think it would just be of the films that I've seen. Chinatown One Flew over and A Few Good Men. But if it's like One Flew over as the very first one, I would probably pick One Flew over and then. Yeah. I mean, honestly, he would never. Would have won for this, but, I mean, he ruined Joker for so long for so many people because he's so fucking good at Batman.
[02:04:57] Speaker C: Yeah,
[02:04:57] Speaker A: he's, like, incredible. Like, his iconic look also. Yeah. A Few Good Men just feels like he dominates that film. And then, of course, the Departed, like, another. It's. It's one of those things where, like, A Few Good Men being nominated but not winning. Him not winning is a shock, looking back at it. But then again, that year was stacked. And then the Departed. Crazy that he wasn't even nominated, because I need to actually look at who was nominated that year for. He would have gotten supported if he did.
[02:05:28] Speaker C: Nick, am I remembering correctly? You do not like the Departed.
[02:05:31] Speaker B: I think the Departed is fine.
I think he kind of ruins it, I think.
[02:05:38] Speaker A: Whoa. Okay.
[02:05:39] Speaker B: My.
My biggest issue with that movie is that I don't think Scorsese exercised the discipline to keep Nicholson from running roughshod all over it with being, like, just the Jack Nicholson Persona.
[02:05:55] Speaker A: Okay.
[02:05:57] Speaker B: I think it detracts from what works about that movie, and it just becomes.
Yeah. I just feel like the second half, like, Nicholson just sort of tramples over that movie in a way that diminishes it for me. I don't dislike it.
[02:06:12] Speaker C: Interesting. Yeah.
[02:06:13] Speaker B: I just was disappointed that that's how it went.
[02:06:19] Speaker C: Interesting.
[02:06:20] Speaker B: That might be the hottest take I have on all of this, actually,
[02:06:24] Speaker C: because for me, I feel like the.
I guess I see what you're saying about, like, it is super Nicholson y in a way that, like, he's let loose, like,
[02:06:33] Speaker B: when he's imitating the.
And I'm just like. By that point, I was like, come on.
[02:06:39] Speaker C: For me, though, I think that deranged quality about him where it lets the goofy side of Jack come into it, for me, it makes that character stand out from what would otherwise be just kind of like your average old mobster.
[02:06:56] Speaker B: Sure.
[02:06:57] Speaker A: It's
[02:06:57] Speaker C: like, oh, he's a cartoon character and a psychopath. Okay.
[02:07:02] Speaker A: And now that we've seen. Cause I think you've seen Infernal affairs, right, Nick? Have you seen all three of them?
[02:07:07] Speaker B: I don't think I've seen all three, but I've seen.
[02:07:09] Speaker A: That's. That's fine. You've watched the best one.
[02:07:11] Speaker B: Yeah,
[02:07:12] Speaker A: but after watching Infernal affairs for the pod and being like, oh, this is the Nicholson character. Like, comparison to see how reeled in. In the original Infernal affairs, what that character is like. It is kind of like, okay, now I'm seeing. It is. It is. Yeah, it's. Honestly, it is interesting what Nicholson brings to it, but it is. He is going full Nicholson. He is very much.
And again, it's one of those things where it's like he's. He's just such a prolific actor. Like, I understand coming from that angle. And honestly, looking at the list, he definitely deserved it more than Walberco.
[02:07:52] Speaker B: Yeah,
[02:07:52] Speaker A: I. This list is kind of crazy. You got Diamond Hansu for Blood diamond, which. He's good in that movie. I know Eddie Murphy from Dream Girls. I forgot. This is the year he got nominated for Dream. Yeah. Jackie Earl Haley for Little Children.
[02:08:05] Speaker B: Yep.
[02:08:06] Speaker A: Didn't. Again, another film I didn't think was the same year at this time. Wahlberg for Departed. And then the winner is Alan Arkin from Little Miss Sunshine.
[02:08:14] Speaker B: Yeah. That was the infamous, like, Eddie Murphy storming out of the Oscars.
Yeah.
Yeah.
[02:08:21] Speaker A: Oh, my gosh. We got Norbit because of Alan Arkin, is what we're finding out right now.
[02:08:25] Speaker C: Thank you,
[02:08:26] Speaker A: Alan.
Andy, what would your three be?
[02:08:31] Speaker C: Well, go. I mean, from his existing nominations, I've only seen five of them, so picking three feels a little silly. But I'll go with One Flu, A Few Good Men and About Schmidt, probably.
I'm
[02:08:49] Speaker A: glad to hear about Schmidt's good. I've actually not seen About Schmidt.
[02:08:51] Speaker C: I've not seen it in a long time, but I just remember being very taken with him.
[02:08:55] Speaker B: Yeah.
[02:08:57] Speaker C: And I would say, like, from any of his movies, I would go One Flew, the Departed, and probably the Shining.
[02:09:05] Speaker B: Yeah, that's a good. Yeah, that's. I
[02:09:08] Speaker A: mean,
[02:09:09] Speaker B: and that was, you know, the. The Academy had, you know, with the Exorcist.
You know, it was. It was not like, they were anti horror if it was prestige
[02:09:19] Speaker A: enough.
[02:09:20] Speaker B: But.
No, that's a good. That's a good call. That's a good left field call. I like that
[02:09:24] Speaker A: Nicholson. And the reason why I didn't put him, because I love the Shining. It's perfect. But I think the reason why I didn't pick him is because it is so.
He goes so hard so fast in terms of, like, when it comes to, like, the. The hotels affecting him. It threw me off.
When I think about, like, it's a great performance. Yeah.
[02:09:44] Speaker C: Like, why is this guy immediately.
[02:09:46] Speaker A: But it's also not. It's also funny when I think about that movie. Movie, I'm like, I want, like, I. When I finally watched the Shining. I was like, I want to know also why Stephen King fucking hates this film. And then when. When Jack Torrance goes crazy in minute 30, I was like, oh, I get it. Like, this character was supposed to be almost like an analog for King. And then fucking Nicholson goes batshit real early.
Yeah, but he's great. He is great. In the Shining, he's again, saying Nicholson has a great career, is a cold take, but he has very fascinating films under his belt.
[02:10:19] Speaker B: I.
So to go back to, like, you know, we talked a little bit about, like, some things that he'd been rumored for in the last, like, you know, 16 years since he last did something.
I do miss him. I do.
I. You know, I mean, granted, you know, 70, you know, 71, 72. When he did his last movie, I still think. I mean, how fascinating would it have been to see, like, you know, him in his 80s doing something? I mean, and,
[02:10:52] Speaker C: yeah,
[02:10:53] Speaker B: you know, I.
And per the Michael Douglas thing that you brought up, Logan, I mean, you know, it sounds like, you know, not unreasonably as he approaches 90, that, you know, there's, you know, that. That, you know, some faculties have started to fail him.
You know, he made, you know, for whatever reason, you know, he doesn't go out anymore.
But I just. I do.
And I don't say this meaning like, you know, oh, what an inconsequential movie to be your last movie. I mean, it's, you know, it's not like a, you know, Gene Hackman, welcome to Moose Port kind of thing. I mean, but I just. He's such a unique performer, and he was taking so many chances well into you know, parts of his career that he didn't need to with, you know, about Schmidt and the Pledge. Honestly, I mean, shit, I would say even Wolf is a. Is a. Is a weird swing,
[02:11:59] Speaker A: you know,
[02:12:01] Speaker B: and a good swing, but I just, you know, and Mars Attacks, like, Mars Attacks is one I'm going to write about here pretty soon. And, you know, playing, like, playing two characters in a movie for, you know, Tim burton in the mid-90s just doesn't have to do it and go that hard, but he does.
I just. I feel like, you know, I would have loved to seen what he would have done, like, in the Sunset era, right? Yeah. I mean,
[02:12:30] Speaker C: sure, sure.
[02:12:30] Speaker B: Or more of the Sunset era.
[02:12:33] Speaker A: Like, it. Yeah, it definitely.
It's interesting because I think when they describe, like, when you're doing a summary, whether it's on Wikipedia or you're talking about Nicholson in general, there is Kind of the conversation of like, he always said that he chose his roles because he had something that kind of really challenged him and mentally kind of really engaged him.
It wasn't the money. He didn't like. The money was probably nice, of course, but, like, looking through his filmography and especially talking about these three films, it's very clear, even if you don't consider them his best.
Well, one flu is his best. You have to consider one of his best. But he just. It shows that he never really half assed it. Or if he did choose a film that just didn't click enough with him, it wasn't because he was forced to do it.
And so it's one of those things where it's like, yeah, I. It would be interesting because it feels like now if they. If he came out of retirement for like a film or two. It literally. It sounds so silly, but it feels genuinely in this current, like, ecosystem we have when it comes to films, especially with actors as old as he is. It have to be like an Orson Welles esque Transformers the movie thing, where it's like, this is. You would never expect this, man. Like when Glenn Close was like, in Aquaman. No, it wasn't Glenn Close. It was Julie
[02:13:51] Speaker B: Andrews.
[02:13:51] Speaker A: Julie Andrews.
[02:13:52] Speaker C: Julie Andrews.
[02:13:54] Speaker A: It was like, that's crazy. But I also kind of love that they went with Julie Andrews and like, Nickel. It would be either that or it would be like a Marvel film where, like, he'd show.
It'd be like five seconds.
[02:14:05] Speaker B: I love
[02:14:05] Speaker A: how you're. I love how
[02:14:06] Speaker B: you're laying out like, like, my monkey paw scenario.
[02:14:10] Speaker C: Yeah. Worst case.
[02:14:11] Speaker A: Well, it's like, it's hard not to, like, like recently, right now, as we're doing this, as we're doing the pod a few weeks ago, Sandra Hooler, who's like, on a fucking build this year.
She's in Doomsday,
[02:14:25] Speaker B: right.
[02:14:25] Speaker A: Why the fuck is she in Doomsday? It's one of those things where it's like, I can see in a weird sense, find a way to bring him back for a movie or two, and that's it. Like, I don't feel like. And I'm not saying that his retirement's not true. I do. I. There is. Unfortunately, we might not ever see him in a movie again. Sure. Do you think us talking about his Oscar wins has made me be like, God, I agree. What would it be like now if he just, like, popped back for a second?
[02:14:54] Speaker B: Yeah. I mean, and. And that's, I guess at the same time, like, you think of like, you know, he hasn't. The flip side of that is, like, there's nothing where he's embarrassed himself.
Right.
[02:15:09] Speaker A: Yeah.
[02:15:10] Speaker B: You know, there isn't a, you know, a righteous kill in there which. Which takes down both De Niro and Pacino, each of whom, you know, have their own fair share of stinkers, but you get two for one in the same movie there.
[02:15:24] Speaker C: Right.
[02:15:24] Speaker B: You know, you know, Redford has a couple of stink, you know, Lions for Lambs is not good.
There's a couple other late period stinkers that he has.
Yes. I'm just trying to think of, like, contemporaries of his.
[02:15:41] Speaker C: Yeah.
[02:15:42] Speaker B: So, I mean, you know, his. His last movie is a. Is probably, you know, like a James Brooks's lightest movie, I would say. Like, like his most like just kind of straight rom com ish, you know, and he still gets to, you know, have like a good time with Reese Witherspoon and Paul Rudd and Owen Wilson and just be the elder statesman.
[02:16:07] Speaker C: Yeah.
[02:16:08] Speaker B: So, yeah.
[02:16:11] Speaker A: God, yeah. I mean, again, a great actor with some very fascinating Oscar wins that I'm glad we started with because as well as, again, Dion Day Lewis, Meryl Streep will do at some point because again, both other two iconic actors of the era that have become just icons in themselves. It is just.
Yeah, I. I love how you made that point, Nick. Like, there is there. There's no Bad Grandpa or Dirty Grandpa.
[02:16:39] Speaker B: Right.
[02:16:40] Speaker A: In. In like Nicholson's kind of. It is kind of this fascinating thing of like those final films. Hell, I'd even say, because, like, the last of his films I probably have seen, I'd not seen his last film with Brooks, but I remember seeing the Bucket List at one point and thinking that was. That was good.
I like him in that. Like, it's very silly. And also it's fun to see him still be playing the Womanizer at like 70.
[02:17:05] Speaker B: Right? Yeah. I mean, I'm probably not as big on the bucket list as other people were, but I mean, like, that's still like if that had been his last movie, like, that's not an unrespectable thing to go.
[02:17:18] Speaker C: Swan song. Yeah.
[02:17:19] Speaker A: Yeah, He's. He's not in Dream Catcher. Like Morgan Freeman. Morgan Freeman, even like that.
[02:17:25] Speaker B: Yeah.
Jack Nicholson definitely having better taste in Stephen King fare than Morgan Freeman for sure.
[02:17:33] Speaker A: But yeah, that's Jack Nicholson's Oscars trilogy. Nick, thank you so much again for joining.
[02:17:39] Speaker C: Thank
[02:17:39] Speaker B: you. No, thank you, guys. It's always a pleasure to chat with you and it was great to revisit a couple of these and finally catch up with Terms of Endearment, which I just. An iconic movie I just hadn't ever gotten around to.
[02:17:55] Speaker C: Well, as we're coming up on Thanksgiving, is there anything you've got in the pipeline that you want to plug?
[02:18:03] Speaker B: Well, we're, you know, as you mentioned, we're getting thick into Oscar contender season, so all of us will be dutifully trying to watch as many of those as is reasonably possible.
[02:18:14] Speaker A: Oh, God, yeah.
[02:18:15] Speaker C: Writing our lists and checking them
[02:18:17] Speaker B: twice.
You know, I.
One of the things that I tried to come back to in earnest this year was kind of a project that I'd started called Coming Around Again, which also kind of ties back to Jack Nicholson, too, because it's a Carly Simon song from a movie he was in called Heartburn, that was in the mid-80s. Another movie he did with Meryl Streep. But anyway, I've tried to more purposefully work on that, and it's movies that I didn't like all that much the first time I saw them, but thinking like, you know, maybe I was just a stupid kid when I watched it and it didn't make any sense.
You know, different life circumstances, things like that.
So one of them I'm rewatching is Toys. I'm going to be working on that for December, which is like the legendarily expensive,
[02:19:09] Speaker A: the Robin Williams.
[02:19:10] Speaker B: Yeah, Barry Levins.
Like, that was
[02:19:13] Speaker A: like.
[02:19:14] Speaker B: That was like.
Like Barry Levinson's Blank Check. Like a movie that he'd been working on, you know, had in the Hopper for years and just lost everyone a lot of money and respect.
But revisiting that and then also closing out, I do a class of series where I look at movies that are, you know, 20th, 30th or 40th anniversary. So I'm doing the Fountain, which will be coming up later this month in November, and then in December, as I mentioned, Mars attacks is 30 years old already.
[02:19:52] Speaker A: Jeez.
[02:19:56] Speaker B: I have always loved Mars Attacks. I mean, it's not one of Tim Burton's best movies, but it is one of his most, I think, rewatchable just for how crazy it is.
[02:20:09] Speaker A: Yeah.
[02:20:11] Speaker B: And. And not even, really, like, audience friendly in an Alien invasion movie kind of way.
[02:20:19] Speaker C: Yeah.
[02:20:19] Speaker A: He's. He's got such wild Blank Check movies. Burton and his, like. And it's crazy that that is tied to a trading card game.
[02:20:28] Speaker B: Right.
[02:20:29] Speaker A: That is like, has one of the greatest casts of that. Like a wild cast. Yeah. And it's also funny to think that that series has, like, a spin off or like a side series called Like Dinosaurs Attack.
[02:20:40] Speaker B: Right.
So those are, those are projects that, that I'll be, you know, coming up here soon. And my hope is to keep them both going into 2027. So.
[02:20:51] Speaker A: Beautiful. Awesome.
[02:20:52] Speaker C: Awesome.
[02:20:53] Speaker A: I will say, have you and Evan done a James Brooks series yet?
[02:20:58] Speaker B: We have not done a James Brooks series. It'd be pretty short. He doesn't really have that many movies.
[02:21:02] Speaker A: No, but can it? But if you do.
[02:21:04] Speaker B: Yeah.
[02:21:05] Speaker A: And I can take. You don't have to give me any rights to this. Could it be called as Brooks as it Gets?
[02:21:09] Speaker B: I mean, we absolutely could do that. And I'd say you guys would have right of first refusal on which titles you wanted to do.
[02:21:18] Speaker C: Refuse.
[02:21:21] Speaker A: He didn't give titles. You can't just refuse the whole thing.
He's okay. Andy does Ellen McKay now because he didn't give any.
[02:21:28] Speaker C: I'll do Ella McKay.
[02:21:30] Speaker A: Oh, no, that's gonna end on bad. He's not gonna like it. No, no. Who else wants to do it?
[02:21:34] Speaker B: I would say give him Spanglish, but that won't end well for him either.
[02:21:37] Speaker A: God, is it funny that when I was growing up, I literally got Spanglish and Punch Drunk Love mixed because they were always the non happy Madison, Adam Sandler films. I'm like, now
[02:21:48] Speaker B: one of them's good.
[02:21:50] Speaker A: Yeah, I know that.
But yeah, I can't wait to read those. Nick, thank again, thank you so much for being on the pod and for closing out November. And it's going to be time for our final two trilogies for the year in December. And we're kicking it off with one that we didn't even curate.
It was one that we like. We had something in this spot that Andy was like, this would be fun to do. And then ultimately a few months ago, we kind of talked and we're like, we could still do this, but it's not really December. We'll push it back. It's not really
[02:22:23] Speaker C: December. It's not much of a trilogy.
There's not a great tie behind it.
[02:22:28] Speaker A: But maybe we'll do it sometime in the future. But until then, we'll pull it out. Let's do something more Christmassy.
And in the process of trying to figure out what we want to put here, our good friend in real life and in the pond, Austin Webster, decided, well, guys, maybe if you haven't done one yet, you should do a Muppets trilogy. And so we decided we're letting him curate what I'm going to call a very Merry Muppets trilogy, which is basically just a Christmas Carol. A Muppets Christmas Carol.
[02:23:00] Speaker C: Yes. 1992. Muppet
[02:23:02] Speaker A: Christmas
[02:23:03] Speaker C: Carol.
[02:23:03] Speaker A: A Very Merry Muppets Christmas from 2002.
[02:23:08] Speaker C: I think the full title is. It's A Very Merry Muppet Christmas movie.
[02:23:12] Speaker A: Yes.
[02:23:12] Speaker C: From 2006.
[02:23:14] Speaker A: And then Letters to Santa from 2008, which is just squeaks past being feature length at 48 minutes.
[02:23:24] Speaker C: And to be clear, disregard the skepticism in our voices. These were curated by Austin, who is a Muppets expert and aficionado.
He's watched Muppet things I had no idea existed.
I don't know if he's seen all three of these, but if he's. If he's
[02:23:43] Speaker A: using
[02:23:44] Speaker C: them. Okay,
[02:23:45] Speaker A: I'll spoil it for you now because I was curious if they were on letterboxd. He watched all the Muppet specials last year.
He watched them all last year in the span of like two days.
[02:23:55] Speaker C: And
[02:23:55] Speaker A: it's. It's funny to see because it's also like,
[02:23:58] Speaker C: because these are not the only Christmas specials that the Muppets have done either. So I'm curious as to his. His decision making process on these three.
[02:24:09] Speaker A: Yeah. Because it's kind of started last year when he asked you for if you knew if you could get him a copy of the John Denver Muppets special.
[02:24:17] Speaker C: Right. Which
[02:24:17] Speaker A: is
[02:24:17] Speaker C: like
[02:24:18] Speaker A: infamously hard to find. I think there's only a VHS rip of that.
[02:24:22] Speaker C: Yeah.
[02:24:23] Speaker A: Which. That was an album. I. My family loves the John Denver Muppets album. It was like a classic Christmas album. Did not know it was a TV special perform.
But yeah, we're excited to do a Muppets trilogy with Austin because at this point, that's the only special interest of his that we have not had a.
A podcast on. I mean,
[02:24:44] Speaker C: we
[02:24:45] Speaker A: already
[02:24:45] Speaker C: talked about his. His favorite actor, Chris
[02:24:47] Speaker A: Pratt and lego.
Yeah. And also Monkey Bone, which will be lost to time.
[02:24:54] Speaker C: Right. Our lost episode,
[02:24:57] Speaker A: his love of animation, Monkey Bone.
[02:24:59] Speaker C: Yeah.
[02:24:59] Speaker A: But, yeah, tune in. I just said when we. Before we started recording.
[02:25:05] Speaker C: December 5th.
[02:25:07] Speaker A: Tune in on December 5th when we do our Muppets Christmas trilogy. I'm still going to work now. I got to workshop the name. I got to look
[02:25:14] Speaker C: at
[02:25:14] Speaker A: what we have, but of course, I'm Logan, so.
[02:25:17] Speaker C: And I'm Andy Carr.
[02:25:18] Speaker A: Thank you so much for listening. Bye.